Andrew Loh
“In Singapore, within half-an-hour, you would be in SGH (Singapore General Hospital), TTSH (Tan Tock Seng Hospital) and within one-and-a-half to two hours flat, you’d know what went wrong.”
- Lee Kuan Yew, TODAY, November, 2003
Recently a friend of mine (we’ll call her ‘Esther’) was admitted to the Accident and Emergency (A&E) department of the Singapore General Hospital (SGH).
Esther had earlier seen her GP who recommended that she consulted doctors at SGH to determine the cause of her illness.
Day One
Registration – 8.40pm
The registration at the triage section of the A&E’s Isolation Ward (IW) was smooth and swift and went without a hitch. The triage nurse was courteous, friendly and apparently highly efficient. We thanked her and took our seats at the waiting area for Esther’s number to be called by the doctor on duty that night.
It was about 8.40pm.
The consultation with the doctor eventually took place at around 10pm – after some 1 hour 20 mins later. Esther was told that she had to be admitted for overnight observation so that more tests could be done to ascertain the cause of her illness.
So, we returned to the waiting area and waited for Esther to be assigned a ward and a bed. In the meantime, a nurse told us that they would find a bed in the IW for Esther to rest temporarily, instead of sitting on the chairs in the waiting area, which was an exercise in endurance for someone who is ill.
It turned out to be a frustrating, excruciating and a very long wait indeed.
At 12.20am, some 3 hours and 40 mins after Esther had registered at the A&E, I approached the triage nurse and asked if they were aware that Esther was waiting for a bed in the IW. (In all those 3 hours 40 mins, we were not informed or updated about when a bed might be available.)
The nurse was very understanding and explained that there were no beds available and that there was nothing they could do. And so the wait continued.
12.50am – 4 hours 10 mins
At 12.50am – 4 hours and 10mins after registration – we were finally informed that a bed was available in the IW’s Fever Zone. The relief – and exhaustion – on Esther’s face was evident. She would be able to rest her tired self finally.
The “Fever Zone”, where the temporary beds were, is a small section within the Isolation Ward. It has two rooms – one for male patients and one for female patients. Each room could hold about 6 to 7 beds. The Fever Zone is the place where patients who have to be warded are temporarily placed while waiting to be admitted to the wards of their choice.
Esther had opted for a B2-plus ward (5 patients in an air-conditioned room).
We were hopeful that we wouldn’t have to wait just as long for Esther to be assigned a bed in the B2-plus ward. The IW ward has its television and lights on 24-hours and patients are wheeled out to the wards and new ones wheeled in, a situation which doesn’t really allow one to rest properly amidst the noise and the comings and goings.
Our hope was misplaced.
The long wait was to last till the next day.
Day Two
9pm – 24 hours 20 mins
At about 9pm on Day Two – 24 hours 20 minutes after registration – Esther was informed that a B2 bed was available and the nurse asked if she wanted it. As a B2 ward is non-air conditioned, as opposed to a B2-plus ward, Esther declined. (See here)
The reason why she declined is because we suspected that Esther might have to stay quite a while in the hospital (as she already had 2 previous unsuccessful blood tests, one at a private hospital and the other with her GP) and because of her constitutional sensitivity to warm temperatures we decided to wait for a B2-plus bed.
Thus, we waited a further 3 hours.
12.50am – 28 hours 10 mins
At about 12 midnight, a nurse informed us that a B2-plus bed was available. Preparation was then made to transfer us to the ward. Esther was put on a wheelchair and wheeled to the corridor of the IW. We were so tired from all the hours of waiting. It was only 15 minutes later that we heard the nurse informing the ward, through a phone call, that Esther was ready to be transferred. A further 12 minutes later, a male nurse arrived to wheel Esther to the B2-plus area of the hospital. Esther had waited for about 30 minutes in the corridor.
It was 12.50am on Day Two before Esther finally managed to put her head down on a bed in a B2-plus ward.
All in all, from registration to being admitted to a B2-plus ward, it took 28 hours and 10 minutes.
Nurses were patient, courteous and professional
Now, before you think that my frustration is directed at the nurses on duty that night, let me say that they were very patient, courteous and professional in their duties. Although they could have done better in some areas – such as keeping us informed of the situation with the availability of the bed – it is understandable as the A&E is a very busy place to work in. The nurses also had to tend to many patients.
I would like to mention, particularly, the nurses at the IW’s Fever Zone. They were compassionate and understanding. This is especially commendable when one considers that most of the patients in the IW that night were elderly and weak.
One of the nurses explained to Esther that the situation has been such since the Chinese New Year. She also said that the wards in Tan Tock Seng Hospital were fully occupied and patients were being directed to SGH. Hence the shortfall of beds there.
A serious problem
Esther was not the only one who had to wait so many hours for a bed. But perhaps she is luckier than others who had had to wait in wheelchairs in the waiting area for hours and hours on end that night we were there – for even the number of beds in the IW is limited.
While MM Lee may be right that “within one-and-a-half to two hours flat, you’d know what went wrong” (even though in Esher’s case the cause of her illness is still unknown 5 days after admission to SGH), the other important thing is the availability, or the squeeze, on the number of hospital beds.
According to the nurses there, this is not a sudden or a temporary hiccup. It has been like this since the Chinese New Year, as earlier mentioned.
While we trumpet the excellence of our clinical healthcare service (and I don’t disagree with this), it is what happens on the ground to each patient that needs to be looked at.
Waiting for more than 28 hours for a bed is simply unacceptable.
I hope that the Minister for Health, Mr Khaw Boon Wan, will put some effort into solving this problem – especially now that he has been called “the best Health Minister Singapore has ever had” by none other than SM Goh himself. (Straits Times)
When you are sick and weak, you shouldn’t be made to endure a frustrating and excruciating 28 hours just for a bed.
And I am sure that Esther is not the only one who has had this experience.
Perhaps the new Khoo Teck Puat hospital in Yishun, scheduled to open in 2010, will help to alleviate the situation. But that is left to be seen.
One can only hope that Singapore’s healthcare system will not become what MM Lee said of the system in the UK, where he experienced “restlessness and unhappiness” when waiting for 45 minutes for an ambulance:
“There’s no connection between those in the system and the patients..”
- MM Lee, (TODAY)
From Esther’s experience, one could say the same for Singapore’s system as well.
——————
HELP keep the voice of TOC alive!
If you like this article, please consider a small donation to help theonlinecitizen.com stay alive. Please note that we can only accept donations from Singaporeans. Thank you for your assistance.Do you have a flair for writing? Volunteer with us. Email us your full name and contact details to theonlinecitizen@gmail.com
Dear Awaken Citizen
I sigh cos i read the postings and feel that everyone is just angry and quick to put a blanket blame on the hospital/the govt; and that is not the answer to the problem at all.
I sigh because that is even more counterproductive to solving the problem; and the reason i write so much is to share my (?insider) perspective that this is everybody’s problem and everyone is part of the problem AND the solution.
I am definitely patriotic but patriotism to Singapore does not equate blind support for the PAP govt.
There are problems with our govt, which is why i am sorry but i can never say my real name (By my employment policy i am not even supposed to express an opinion about health care without approval from our public relations office! So you can write to the forum pages about what you feel about hosp/doctors/nurses etc, i can’t…or at least i can’t say what i really think).
I don’t think we are truly democratic and i certainly fear the repercussions of opposing the authorities, but let’s not say everything they do is bad, just like not everything they do is good!
At the end of the day, all my spew is not about supporting the govt but trying to be “fair”.
And of course you should not trust me or anyone else completely! But be open-minded, think about it, and check it out on your own…
I am on govt scholarship of some sort but the taxpayers money allocated to me is inadequate and i have to “tampa” with my own money.I am also bonded for more years and for more money than the scholarship is worth…so if your concern is that i am wasting taxpayer’s money, i can say with full conscience i am not.
Thanks patriot for your comments. I am not great, or I am only as great as any other typical singaporean; who despite not having anything, put our little red dot on the world stage. And i am also as ugly as the next singaporean who gorges at buffets and litter in JB.
sigh, you are cool. Like you, I think singapore is great and can become greater and not everyone need to be pro PAP for that to happen.
Sigh,
I hope your return to sg will provide some relieve to our overly stressed health care system. As a health care worker your inputs and contributions are of great importance and if u see that something is done wrongly of the system, i truly hope people like you can voice out and be firm in your stand. I do hope singaporeans help singaporeans if not we are doom as this gahmen only help if it doest cost money to them. After all we singaporeans are not asking for world class medical treatment but good enough medical care at affordable prices. I am disappointed a rich gahmen we have cant even provide the free medical care to the very poor and everything cost so much for the middle class singaporeans. Where are we heading > Japan ‘s standard of living then we are all facing trouble times ahead and it could well happen in a few years or so.
To determine the quality of health service,one must compare the standard as follows:
1) the number of hospital beds per 10,000 population
2) the number of doctors per 1,000 population
3) the number of nurses per 1,000 population
currently most A&E Departments are centrally located at the central locations of the island and the catchment areas are not evenly distributed thus it jam up the A&E Departments.
Currently, we do not know the standards, the authority failed to inform us or even no such standards
The authority must set a standard based on world standard as the performance indicator.
We need more hospitals for the northern and eastern sectors to meet with the higher dense population demands and also to fulfill the ambulance response time for critical accidents,so as to ease the heavy workload for the A&E Departments.
how come that old guy always choose to compare singapore to countries that have don’t do very well??
And they charged top dollars for health care …we are being fleeced again.
would you say that you have done an apple-apple comparison?
LKY, pls explain.
now you all know..when mrs harryLEE waltz in..all her 1st class room was ready..fulLEE purified.. she didn’t even have to wait for more than 1 minute…
sarek home: ‘more hospital space is designated to serve medical tourists.’
Medical tourists should be attended to at the private hospitals if possible. In Ester’s case it is indeed frustrating and unfortunate that she fell ill during the CNY period. Nevertheless the Hospitals should have more wards built to cater to the increased population and patients. We are also short of staffs like nurses and doctors. So Singaporeans must learn to accept foreign talents.
Maybe the new Ng Teng Fong Hospital will help alleviate the problem.
On another issue. The Marine Parade Polyclinic. It is too small and I can see it cannot expand further because the upper floors are occupied by the Church which use it as a library. Can the Govt talk to the Church to relocate to a new space so the Marine Polyclinic can expand to serve the community better. The Church and Polyclinic should work hand in hand as the Polyclinic looks after the present life and the Church looks after the afterlife.
Seems the waiting period has not improved:
http://singaporealternatives.blogspot.com/2010/03/sorry-no-enough-minister-khaw.html