Top

Bangladeshi workers stranded, Singaporeans step forth to help

Thursday, 18 December 2008, 7:28 pm | 1,538 views

Andrew Loh

This is an update on the situation with the 179 Bangladeshi workers who were reported by TOC to have been abandoned by their employers. The following update is provided by a good-hearted Singaporean who was moved by their plight to help out today at the dormitory at Tagore Lane. He wishes to remain anonymous.

I have, since this morning, spoken to TWC2 (Transient Workers Count Too) and brought some bottled water down for the workers at Tagore Lane. Perry Tong from the Workers’ Party was there and he brought along some groceries, and also Wee Kiat the journalist from TODAY who covered the news – he’s there not for work but to see how he can help.

The latest development is as such – TWC2 has negotiated with Tipper and made it their responsibility to provide 3 meals a day for the workers. They will also be relocated to another dorm in Yishun, owned by Tipper, on the 20th.

But what the workers need are more than food and lodging. They haven’t been paid for two months, so they are running out of basic necessities, such as washing powder, soap, toothpaste, toilet paper etc.

I should be able to gather some donations by tonight, and with the money, i should be able to buy some toiletries to last them for another week.

For now the situation is stable, but we will need to monitor further. (BTW, TCW2 has limited funds as they are already bogged down feeding up to 300 people a day.)

As you can see, until the workers get employed again, we have to keep the help steady, and I doubt I can get a constant stream of donations from the same people.

I’m sure many readers at TOC would love to help. I’ve never done this before, asking for donations from online sources, maybe you guys are better coordinators.

Editor’s note: For now, and until we are sure donations can be collected, readers who wish to donate should get in touch with the people from TWC2. You can contact them through their website here.
———

*** See related posts

 

Email this article to a Friend Email this article to a Friend

Bookmark this

Comments

81 Responses to “Bangladeshi workers stranded, Singaporeans step forth to help”

    1) Overclock Singapore on December 18th, 2008 7.55 pm

    More good years, 3rd world shameful employment practice in Uniquely Singapore day 2… reuters please report this to the world what million dollars minister are worth their pay.

    2) me on December 18th, 2008 10.06 pm

    great warm hearted Singaporean we have here. if it were our politicians, they would definitely attempt to show sympathy and try to hog the limelight. and for that matter, no politicians even bothered. all want to collect those fees paid by all of them, but when it comes to their welfare, suddenly all the hands wash off. how shameful is this?

    3) smallvice585 on December 18th, 2008 10.20 pm

    For now, and until we are sure donations can be collected, readers who wish to donate should get in touch with the people from TWC2. Editor’s note

    Why is there even red tape for donation? To discourage Singaporeans from doing the right thing since our ruling elites themselves do not want to do the right thing?

    4) SZ on December 18th, 2008 11.01 pm

    but kudo to Perry Tong for his effort

    5) Overclock Singapore on December 18th, 2008 11.31 pm

    All eyes everyone, out of job crisis has just begin.. more jobless from china, malaysia, philipines, india foreign workers going to be out of job soon + 2009 geylang lorong golden age will prosper with foreign jobless people as more company going chapter 11 soon. Who says golden age won’t exist.. check out geylang lorong next year everyone, thanks to mom million dollars policy. Reuters, need a headline on asia front page… this is it!!!

    6) moshedyan on December 18th, 2008 11.47 pm

    how to help?
    when even the bangala embassy not helpin their owned citizens @ all?
    every evennin without fail
    in little india off hindu lane
    there will be a lorry laden with vegetarian rice packets/water for
    ANY persons who just want a free large vegetarians dish rice
    trust me on this
    this is enough
    one shouldn’t complaint
    for the hindu communities in serangoon road are workin very very hard to feed our overflows of foreign talent workers
    which is one far too many
    as for our overpaid ministers
    they one day will be repaid by Heavens’ eyes

    7) Zefly (aka Joshua Chiang) on December 19th, 2008 12.20 am

    hi smallvice

    I think the rationale makes sense. I have dealt with some charity work before, and while we appreciate all the help the donors give, have the time they give things the needy don’t need. So if everyone rush to donate all kinds of things, it may not be the best way to help. We should help, but help wisely. For now I think cash donation is best as TWC2 would know the workers’ needs better.

    8) gemami on December 19th, 2008 8.31 am

    Great job TOC for the effort to show these foreign brothers of ours that there are people in Singapore who do care for the human life. Let’s hope the people who are supposed to take care of them do the same thing and give them what rightfully belong to them.

    More importantly, I hope they do not go on to strip them of their dignity and make it seem like they are a bunch of beggers asking for too much. Give them what belong to them, their wages, their food and their dignity.

    Hi #6) moshedyan, let’s be a little more sensitive here. Please do not ask how to help when their own embassy is not helping them. Must we reach out to help only when others do so? Can’t we have our own backbones and do the right thing ourselves?

    If you think there are a lot of ready food in little india, then make the effort to either go tell this poor people or to bring the food to them. If you cannot do this, then don’t put them down because they too might have their reasons, like you, why they cannot reach those food? I am also sure, food is the furthest thing from their minds right now.

    9) Zefly (aka Joshua Chiang) on December 19th, 2008 8.41 am

    #6) moshedyan,

    No money take bus how to go down?

    10) Gilbert Goh on December 19th, 2008 8.55 am

    I think TOC will eventually have to apply for a license to run itself like a VWO (licensed by MCYS) the way it goes. It is like a welfare arm of TOC runs by volunteers. Of course, it needs to be registered like any private enterprise with ROC. As a VWO, there will be general auditting yearly and AGM has to take place.

    This way, TOC can collect donations from readers and public who are sympathetic to certain sectors that they have reported so far. Politics and social causes are very inter-twined. Politics are after all about people.

    As dealing with money can be a touchy issue, it is best to do it legitimately and sensibly. We have seen how big corporations (NKF) ran aground with financial collections.

    Nevertheless, I am happy that TOC has slowly evolved into social causes. This is the right path to go into. There is so much we can write or talk about politics.

    TKl has showed us by walking the talk at HLP for the minibond investors.

    Keep it up TOC!

    11) gemami on December 19th, 2008 9.41 am

    I agree with Gilbert that TOC has to consider if it wants to pursue social causes and that it would be good for it to register a welfare entity under its arm to serve this end. It entails full time commitment and transparency especially with donations and money matters.

    I have also suggested this somewhere here in TOC that TOC undertake this challenge as it is becoming the alternative voice of the people, slowly but surely. Go sit down together and think about it. Good to have Vision and Mission statements to go along with it.

    Anternatively, TOC might want to retain itself as “just a blog” and continue what it is currently doing while at the same time working closely with established interest groups which might be more than willing to help out in causes identified by TOC.

    Whichever way, there is no running away now that the fire is burning brightly. Food for thought TOC.

    12) loop on December 19th, 2008 10.10 am

    The person or company who brought them in should provide air-tickets to send them back to their own country.

    13) sarek_home on December 19th, 2008 10.12 am

    10) Gilbert Goh on December 19th, 2008 8.55 am

    I think TOC will eventually have to apply for a license to run itself like a VWO (licensed by MCYS) the way it goes. It is like a welfare arm of TOC runs by volunteers.

    I hope there is enough VWO groups around to meet the need that TOC will not have to do it. In this particular case, TWC2 is the better entity to collect donation and coordinate helps for this group of foreign workers.

    It is better for social development that TOC is partnering with VWOs instead of becoming a VWO.

    14) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 10.40 am

    [i]Hi #6) moshedyan, let’s be a little more sensitive here. Please do not ask how to help when their own embassy is not helping them. Must we reach out to help only when others do so? Can’t we have our own backbones and do the right thing ourselves?

    If you think there are a lot of ready food in little india, then make the effort to either go tell this poor people or to bring the food to them. If you cannot do this
    [/i]
    i liked you alot
    100% kiasu kiasee singaporean spoiltbrat mentality
    people out of goodhearted give you food
    give you lobangs
    you want it to be delivered to YOUR doorsteps as well?
    wow!
    when i was in london
    every evennin WITHOUT fail
    i have to walk
    more than a mile
    just to eat @ the subsidised malaysian hall meal for just o.50 pence
    don’t come here hailing
    hail mary
    please send me food to my quarter
    now you know
    why singaporeans like YOU
    can never qualifiys for the survivors contest….

    15) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 10.42 am

    [i]Zefly (aka Joshua Chiang) on December 19th, 2008 8.41 am #6) moshedyan,

    No money take bus how to go down?
    [/i]
    good question
    now do you need a REAL answer from me?
    my upstairs neigbours
    also asked me the same thinggie
    i told them
    try
    62353535

    16) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 10.46 am

    ok peeps
    want to discuss on dignity?
    want to seek assistance?
    GOD says
    god help those who helped themselves
    proven theories
    when i am broke
    which do happenned
    if you still don’t know my situation by all my contributions
    on most topics here
    i eat udong @ $0.80/packet
    sometime 2 or 3 times a week
    even tried
    4 days in a row
    both lunch/dinner
    i survived
    simply because i know
    when to have proper meals
    when not
    please don’t come here singing
    FOOD is not in their minds right now
    ~zhee~

    17) The Singapore Daily » Blog Archive » Daily SG: 19 Dec 2008 on December 19th, 2008 10.55 am

    [...] in a Strange Land – TOC: Bangladeshi workers stranded, Singaporeans step forth to help – All the electric stars are shining: A few notes on [...]

    18) Zefly (aka Joshua Chiang) on December 19th, 2008 11.06 am

    moshdeyan…

    why are you so angry? Hugs….

    19) gemami on December 19th, 2008 11.10 am

    Hi moshedyan,

    it’s just a simple call to be sensitive to the situation, and I do not see it in you to have such a quality from the replies you gave. I sincerely hope you see beyond your own experiences and give thanks that you are more adaptable than others who may not be endowed with the same adaptabilities.

    All of us have our “I-have-been-there-and-done-that-to-survive’ experiences or theories to tell but the difference is we do not then tell everyone else that they ought to be as clever as we are.

    Thank God you are smarter and wordly-wise than others.

    20) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 11.17 am

    what does it GOD gotta do with it?
    God didn’t place food on my table
    i go out to seek it
    in 1 way or another
    you on the other hand
    act as though
    you can empowered our government to assist
    my experience here is
    NOT to boost
    it for you all
    to see
    the REAL situations around us
    as i have said before
    nothing is for FREE
    those foreign workers?
    am i not a foreign worker myself
    when i venture to london?
    have you been homeles/hungry?
    i have
    have you ever slept in a smelly phonebooth sitting down
    or in a bustop really really a bustop on a cold winter night
    with a policeman who came knocking
    asking why are you camping in a bustop
    and let you sleep throughout the night peacefully?
    last but not least
    have you ever sleep in a real broken down temple
    with poor monks giving you charity?
    so what is
    YOUR experience?

    21) gemami on December 19th, 2008 11.32 am

    Hi moshedyan,

    We are not here to compare your plight with others. We are not here to ‘boast’ who have suffered more. While you go on harping over your poor state of affairs in times gone past, the world has to continue to rotate and time does not stand still.

    All these things you have written here would be better if spoken into the ears of those poor workers. Maybe they can learn a lesson or two from you. Why waste your time telling it to us? Someone might just drop in with stories of their own and then you will have no where to hide your face.

    Just a little biscuuit for you to digest. Have you heard of a place call ‘Smokey Mountain’?.

    If you do not like God, even though you were the first to use the word, then I say, thank your lucky stars.

    22) The Prince. on December 19th, 2008 12.05 pm

    I appreciate moshedyan opinion cos the lesson i draw from his poems is not to think becos i got money & comfortable in my HDB flat or aircon office typing messages, that i know what is best FOR other peoples and can tell them what to do. People is funny one – we want to do kind, charitable, generous, compassion deeds becos it is the right thing to do.
    anyway my wuliao point is to say don’t count on god(that’s the nietzschen Moshedyan for u) or even my own ’self’ to do the right thing cos i think big big things like the political system, education system, transport system, housing system, healthcare system n so on must PCK Pte Ltd renovate first so that we can live in a society that got true openness & bruddership, regardless of lace, language or leligion.

    23) gemami on December 19th, 2008 12.19 pm

    # 6) moshedyan, how to help? when even the bangala embassy not helpin their owned citizens @ all?

    Hi The Prince,

    Thanks for your royal perspective and I do agree that there are lessons, lots even, that we can learn from Moshedyan’s writings.

    However, i do not think his message was, “not to think becos i got money & comfortable in my HDB flat or aircon office typing messages, that i know what is best FOR other peoples and can tell them what to do”

    He posted his first comment by asking how to help when even the bangala embassy is not helping its own citizens and then went on to described his innovative ideas for survival which he felt he, and only he, the only one in the whole wide world, has the right to tell. The rest of his posts are continuation of this boast.

    I made a simple call for him to be sensitive to the plight of these workers, that was all. Suddenly, God and lobangs and London came into the picture. What more can I say.

    24) patriot on December 19th, 2008 12.19 pm

    Hi Friends;

    Let us not be over generous or too down to earth.

    moshedyan has some wisdoms while the generous have too kind hearts.

    Remember the case where a family received over $400K donation when the man of the family jumped into the MRT track infront of a oncoming train? Did You see how the family was treated by the neighbours, hawkers and schoolmates shown by our telecasts? They(the family members) were ostracized, how funny, fuzzy and unfathomable we can be. Outpouring of sympathies turned sour before the grief of the family even subsided.

    I am sadden by the inhumane treatments of the foreign workers and their plights but I am just as disappointed that they loaned SIN$5000 to $10,000 just to work for a meagre income overseas(away from their families and homes). This reported sum of monies are huge amounts(value) in their countries of origin which mean that the loans could be seed monies or capitals to start off some kind of small businesses or primary product industries(domestic) in their own hometowns.

    Sacrificing and forsaking much of the family togetherness in exchange for a pittance to work overseas may not be the wise. I suspect them to have wrong priorities, forgive me for digressing.

    By now Singaporeans should have known that while there are people here who have no qualm exploiting others, including ourself, there are also kind souls everywhere in SINgapore. There were floods of sympathies everytime a sad story is publicized and You know what? Much of those misplaced sympathies are exploited again and again by schemers.

    We have to be kind and sympathetic but also got to check our emotions to be rational and purposeful. I call for direct donations instead of going through second or third parties.

    patriot

    25) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 12.20 pm

    gemami on December 19th, 2008 11.32 am Hi moshedyan,

    We are not here to compare your plight with others. We are not here to ‘boast’ who have suffered more.

    Just a little biscuuit for you to digest. Have you heard of a place call ‘Smokey Mountain’?.

    If you do not like God, even though you were the first to use the word, then I say, thank your lucky stars.[/i]

    i simply asked you
    what is YOUR experience
    you have
    nonne to start with
    i have leechers who wants to lean on me
    some of them are my owned relatives/old best kakis
    i simply told them
    where were you
    when i was in dire straits?
    i have one true friend
    who is indeed a real friend in need
    i just express myself one day many years ago
    my bank book went dry
    immediately without a doubt
    he came over
    i wasn’t in
    he dropped $50 for me
    when he himself is a family man
    i owed him his kindness
    and when i striked 4D
    no not the jackpot
    i brought him to china for a holiday
    together with another 2 other kakis
    (which wasn’t that truthful @ all)
    yet this same bloke sticked with me throughout the holidays
    we enjoyed together
    till today
    we still are good kakis
    unfortunately
    bad gloomin future for him
    he just got retrenched few months ago
    with a brand new car to maintain
    i also cannot help him
    so when people asked me for a handout
    i alway replied
    why?
    you don’t have limbs?

    26) gemami on December 19th, 2008 12.36 pm

    Hi patriot,

    No one could have said it better:

    moshedyan has some wisdoms while the generous have too kind hearts.

    Hi moshedyan,

    Let’s not get carried away. I am taking a step back because deep down in our hearts I believe we are standing on common ground and we do feel for these workers. I understand fully your point of view that these people could have done more to help themselves like the examples you have shared about yourself.

    How much more they could have done for themselves is open to debate because when placed in a situation like theirs, when they were expecting promises to be carried out, they were left in the lurch without any knowledge of when will happen next.

    For example, they were waiting for food to come but it did not come. If they had known that food was not going to come, I am sure they would have done something about it and go look for some other alternatives. Bottomline is, they were waiting for things that ought to have happen to happen but it did not happen and they were left in the lurch.

    It was later that they had to contend with the fact that their employers have disappeared and this is why we call it a plight.

    I am fine if you want to continue to share your experiences with us but I ask that you respect my wish to keep mine to myself, suffice to say, they are not too far off your own experiences. This is besides the topic of interest.

    You would make a very wise man if you can tame your anger. It can be clearly felt in your writings.

    Let me be the first to apologize to you if I had offended you in any way. I am not here to pick fights.

    Cheers :)

    27) Poorthing on December 19th, 2008 12.51 pm

    Mosyedyan, perhaps you are sour and bitter bcos when you needed help, a little kindness from people back in London you did not manage to get any from the system nor from the people there? Do you thing that you deserve it ?
    So you feel that given these similar condition of these foreign workers they should also learn the hard way. Would’nt you have appreciated it if the policeman had shown you a little compassion or a place for shelter from the cold winter night?

    28) sucs on December 19th, 2008 12.57 pm

    moshedyan … u really lol … wat a typical singaporean

    29) 1st Lady on December 19th, 2008 12.58 pm

    The difference between Mosyedyan & the FWs:

    You were alone , there is 179 of them
    It was winter, It is a desirable 28 degree in a tropical climate
    You had nowhere to go, they have a shelter over their heads at the moment
    You’ve got noone to blame, they are blaming their employers and agents
    More importantly you were in 1st world London,
    Now you are in 1st world Singapore!
    They should be able to survive without any help eh?

    30) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 1.05 pm

    [i]Would’nt you have appreciated it if the policeman had shown you a little compassion or a place for shelter from the cold winter night?[/i]
    and get lockup in a jailcell
    missing my 7am 1 and only bus to london?
    what so bitter?
    i chose to go oversea to work
    the 179 all come to singapore together?
    they too must adapt
    onced again
    you are talking about numbers
    a packed of wolves
    remembered
    opened your eyes
    go around the world
    see for yourself
    how they lived
    only then will you appreciate
    do you want to live the early 60s/70s?
    try visiting china villages
    today
    they still don’t know
    or even hear the word
    economic depression

    31) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 1.11 pm

    do you all want to know why i was homeless in london?
    i chose to?
    the employer fired me
    as you too should have known
    i was a workpermit holder
    simply because i refused to do slavery job which is not my
    DUTY in the 1st place?
    ok let me give you an insight
    if i employed you as a waiter
    i also demand that you cleaned all the hotel toilets as well
    when there are no patron in the hotel cafe
    would you stoop to that level
    in london?
    i went to ministry of labour
    submit my complains
    the next day
    the employer terminate my employment sayin i breached a contract?
    within 24 hours
    i must vacate the hostel permise
    so what is the difference between me and the 179 worker?

    32) gemami on December 19th, 2008 1.12 pm

    Hi moshedyan,

    It’s not nice calling people all sort of names. A pack of wolves? How so? Do you know how a pack of wolves behave? Have you been beaten up during your escapades and ending up with broken limbs and slashes all over? Get over your anger, please, for goodness sake.

    33) gemami on December 19th, 2008 1.17 pm

    so what is the difference between me and the 179 worker?

    Your’s is your own doing, you decided not to stoop so low to wash toilet but rather sleep in a realy really bus-top.

    These 179 workers were not given this choice even.

    34) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 1.23 pm

    [i]gemami on December 19th, 2008 1.17 pm
    Your’s is your own doing, you decided not to stoop so low to wash toilet but rather sleep in a realy really bus-top

    wow!
    i am really really amaze
    you would indeed bent over to wash toilet
    so what next?
    sleeping with the hotel general manger as well?
    what wrong for calling them a pack of wolves?
    even our minister run liked a pack of wolves
    what is GRC?
    which country have this system?
    isn’t the wolves here showing their teeth
    not only do this wolves wants your money
    they also wants YOUR organs
    proved to me
    i am WRONG
    again
    in my this wolves statement

    35) gemami on December 19th, 2008 1.29 pm

    Hi moshedyan,

    I shall not persist with this argument if you continue to be persistently insensitive. I am retracting my earlier apology to you because I had hoped you could be wise but you have continued to show that you would rather let your anger dictate your wisdom.

    I was also wrong to suggest that you felt for the plight of these poor workers. You do not have any concern for them except disdain for not being as resilient as yourself.

    As long as you continue to allow your anger and hatred of grow within you, you will never be a wise man but one who sees the world with anger and hatred. They have engulfed you too deep.

    God bless you, I sincerely pray. Good bye and good luck.

    36) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 1.40 pm

    gemami on December 19th, 2008 1.29 pm Hi moshedyan,

    You do not have any concern for them except disdain for not being as resilient as yourself.Good bye and good luck.
    don’t prayed for me
    prayed for them
    concerned for them?
    all this while
    how do you want me to show concerned?
    by holding their hands
    and says
    may Allah go with you perhaps?

    stopped sitting behind your aircon office
    and start walking…

    37) Arrogant Bum on December 19th, 2008 2.18 pm

    Moshedyan, you are not unlike moir.

    38) beloved citizen on December 19th, 2008 2.57 pm

    Moshedyan, you are very stubborn.
    Just let this F Workers get the help from our beloved citizen.

    39) Gilbert Goh on December 19th, 2008 4.02 pm

    Patriot

    I think these Fws must have calculated their sums before they borrow or beg to pay the $8,500 voyage to prosperous Singapore. They must be promised much more or else do you think they will come?

    They must be shocked to see the condition that they are in right now.

    To me, they are fleeced or hoodwinked to come as 100 X $8,500 agent fees is alot of money. One can retire atfer that.

    I agreed with you that I prefer to give directly to an organisation than going to another party e.g. TWC2. I normally give according to my conscience and gut feeling.

    If TOC asks for a donation to this group of workers, I will give. If you ask me to give and they will channel the donation to TWC2 i will think twice. I know and trust TOC – it’s that simple.

    It’s up to TOC now I guess. By applying as a VWO arm of TOC, there will be more planning and work to be done. However, looking at SIngapore now, there seems to be no end in what a VWO can do even though there are many VWOs now. By combining the socio-political site with actual ground work, TOC will be a real force to be reckoned with.

    Not that many VWOs can appeal to the general public like TOC. It is more like a brand name by itself already.

    Point to consider TOC.

    40) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 4.11 pm

    did i stopped any of you
    for helping the foreign workers?
    you are free to do whatever you wants to do
    from your aircon office to your starbuck cafe
    as for me
    i am free
    not to help any foreign workers @ all
    when all my neigbours upstairs
    can’t even lived a day to day without sadness
    so who is stubborn here?
    the one that sit in an aircon office
    or the one who can hear the sadness cries
    every morning?

    41) gemami on December 19th, 2008 4.25 pm

    Hmm…. very strong and valid argument, Gilbert. I second the call for TOC to seriously consider. My cheque book is ready.

    42) smallvice585 on December 19th, 2008 4.27 pm

    sarek_home (#13),

    I agree with you. TOC would do better by partnering with other VWOs. What TOC should be doing now is to build up its key competencies (news-making, reporting, analysis, perspective and communication) first before expanding into too many areas.

    I don’t think there is a lack of VWOs in Singapore but rather the lack of awareness to social issues, compounded by apathy and selfishness that have led to illusion that there are no social problems in Singapore just because MSM doesn’t report these issues as often as PAP’s merits.

    43) NORTHGATE2007 on December 19th, 2008 5.16 pm

    Did they(MEN IN WHITE) department *Ministry of Labour, KNOW This Workers
    stranded??

    44) patriot on December 19th, 2008 6.59 pm

    Hi gemami, Gilbert Goh and all Friends;

    I want to say that TOC has been doing a great job, thank You Folks very much.

    And I wish that more people in Singapore as well as elsewhere will visit this great site and give it pointers, criticisms and helps. However, I do feel that we should not be asking too much and having too many requests from TOC. Many, I believe, like smallvice585 and me, share the views of sarek_home(#13) that TOC partner other VWOs.

    As the social and political developments largely run counter to the wishes and hopes of the people, more are finding TOC helpful and a effective organization for us to express our views, exasperations, frustrations and even despondences. We are awared that the Government monitors TOC and its’ members have appeared and been featured in the MSM.

    Of course, we wish that more will volunteer with TOC and offers of assistances in equipments and services are made in postings as we have read them, they augur well for TOC.

    Sentiments and expressions are sometimes very vehement due to bad experiences and sufferings, it is quite understandable. Hopefully, we should do our best to avoid being personal, confrontational and combative. We all like to be constructive, I am sure. Venting and ranting against policies and rules will be very acceptable to all but nevertheless we can still try our best to be friendly and polite.

    Have a good weekend!

    patriot

    45) moshedyan on December 19th, 2008 7.58 pm

    [i]patriot on December 19th, 2008 12.19 pm Hi Friends;

    Let us not be over generous or too down to earth.

    moshedyan has some wisdoms while the generous have too kind hearts.

    Remember the case where a family received over $400K donation when the man of the family jumped into the MRT track infront of a oncoming train? Did You see how the family was treated by the neighbours, hawkers and schoolmates shown by our telecasts? They(the family members) were ostracized, how funny, fuzzy and unfathomable we can be. Outpouring of sympathies turned sour before the grief of the family even subsided.
    [/i]

    here is the main story
    read the link
    sorry toc
    is not that i want to hijack or whatever
    i was challenged
    what would i do
    if someone come knocking…

    http://www.findsingapore.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=9508
    or this
    http://www.youngpap.org.sg/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=23192&highlight=noelofarc

    while you are @ it
    try doing a seached engine
    on moshedyan/matagandhi in youngpap
    don’t says i didnt give feedbacks @ all
    thank you
    have a nice weekends for all

    46) seaporter on December 20th, 2008 12.18 am

    Hurray to all kind hearted Singaporean who cares for human rather than the current regime of elite who only think for themselves. But still remember that people still desire a merry Christmas … Donate to the BBSGB Sharity Gift Box for the poor Singaporean will be extremely kind and helpful this Christmas season.

    47) agongkia on December 20th, 2008 9.19 am

    I have a different view

    48) Zefly (aka Joshua Chiang) on December 20th, 2008 10.37 am

    mosehdyan..

    Why are you still so angry? Hugs hugs

    49) patriot on December 20th, 2008 11.17 am

    Hi moshedyan;

    thank You for your Response#Post45 !

    patriot

    50) moshedyan on December 20th, 2008 1.15 pm

    [i]) Zefly (aka Joshua Chiang) on December 20th, 2008 10.37 am mosehdyan..

    Why are you still so angry? Hugs hugs

    Current score: 0 49) patriot on December 20th, 2008 11.17 am Hi moshedyan;

    thank You for your Response#Post45 !

    patriot
    [/i]

    you are welcome
    you certainly deserved a respected reply

    as for zefly
    not angry lark..
    its my nature

    51) anon on December 20th, 2008 3.30 pm

    This mess is created by MOM.

    Shouldn’t MOM do something?!

    I hate to say this, but the truth is … if they can’t find jobs now .. they will not later.

    Since they have no job, cancel their work permit and send them home.

    Fine the companies involved, both main and sub-contractor and compensate the workers accordingly.

    Frankly, the longer they stay .. the worse their situation will become. And they can’t expect to live on singaporean charity on long term basis.

    MOM should start having some SOPs on such events propping up by the dozens soon.

    Man, bunch of useless beauracrats.

    52) gemami on December 20th, 2008 5.34 pm

    Hi TOC, please release my comments. They are important. Thanks.

    53) gemami on December 20th, 2008 6.04 pm

    Okay, I think my post is too long, I hsall break it up into 3 parts.

    Part One

    Hi Patriot and Friends,

    Thanks for all your concern even though it baffles me what the fuss
    is all about. I simply called for sensitivity in the posting of comments.
    What I got in return was a biographical redention that derided these
    workers for being useless and for not showing initiatives to help themselves.

    When I saw that my message was not going anywhere, I decided to take a
    step back, apologize for any hurtful words uttered and walked away. It wasn’t
    enough, the litany of lamentations continued but what really got to me was
    the name calling and insinuations that I am in my own little aircon office and
    drinking starbucks coffee and what not. I ignored them all.

    Tell me, did I do anything wrong? The attacks continued even as I kept silent.

    Patriot and freinds, I am now going to do something I did not planned to ever
    do. I am going to give my answers to Mo. I am doing this on your accounts
    because I feel I owe it to you for showing concern.

    Please allow me to now turn my attention to Moshedyan. I hope TOC will grant
    me a little more space than usual because I feel Moshedyan has a lot to offer,
    with his life’s experiences. Only if he quells his anger and hatred and come out
    of the coldness that he has decided for himself.

    Moshedyan, you asked me what my experiences are and I gave you a hint when
    I mentioned Smokey Mountain. I shall come to this later.

    When I was a small boy, poverty was my constant partner. So I know what it
    means to be poor and seeing your own parents struggling to provide for the
    family. We would walk miles just to attend school with no food, no ppocket
    money. Back home, it is a constant struggle my parents had to face to put
    food on the table, oftentimes they would comprise of biscuits and bread crumbs
    if we were lucky. If not, we would remained hungry for a few days or so.

    Small matter, most people at that time had to endure such hardships.

    54) gemami on December 20th, 2008 6.09 pm

    Part 2

    Okay, let’s go one step up, Smokey Mountain. This is a place found in the
    Philippines. I was rather active there back in 1995. In case you are wondering
    what the hell I am talking about, it is a place where the Filipinos dump there
    rubbish, the garbage centre of the Philippines before it was cleaned up recently.
    Have you seen small children eat rotting garbage? Have you seen how they live,
    building their little shacks around this huge heap of garbage that rises to 5 maybe
    6 storeys high? Well, I have, I was there.

    In case you think this is nothing, let me put you in a right frame of mind. Once,
    we had a group of Singapore visitors, so keen to see and understand what the
    fuss was about Smokey Mountain. They made their way there. One full kilometre
    away, they had to stop their vehicle. You know why, Moshedyan? They had to
    stop the vehicle because the stench was too much to bear. They all came out
    to throw up. Yes, vomit. But these were brave people with lots of love in their
    hearts. They finally got to the insides of Smokey Mountain and stayed there for
    half an hour.

    No big deal, you say? fine with me because it is no big deal to me either.

    55) gemami on December 20th, 2008 6.10 pm

    This is no good, TOC is having problem, guess parts 2 and 3 will have to wait. Sorry.

    56) smallvice585 on December 20th, 2008 6.27 pm

    Since they have no job, cancel their work permit and send them home.Anon (#51)

    Firstly, it is illegal to withhold employee’s salary for more than a month, so the foreign workers have the right to their salaries in this case.

    Secondly, MOM holds a S$8,500 bond for each foreign worker and because this is a clear case of abandonment, that bond ought to be used to pay for the workers’ passage home and some repartition for grievances caused.

    Thirdly, if the total cost exceeds the S$8,500 bond, then MOM should take Tipper and the Subcontractor to court to recover the expenditure for diffusing the problem caused by Tipper’s and the Sub-Contractor’s irresponsibility.

    57) Zefly (aka Joshua Chiang) on December 20th, 2008 6.46 pm

    Germani! I want part 2 and 3! I like trilogies!!!!!!

    hurry hurry… (next time, film them back to back like LOTR…)

    58) Observer(SG-HK) on December 20th, 2008 8.27 pm

    Dear gemami,

    I feel the need to share my perspective with you in anticipating your part 3 of your stories installed.

    My personal advice to you is to simply ignore and disregard. I think readers are intelligent enough to differentiate and make their conclusions on views expressed. I believe it is more useful to channel energy to try to help find ways or suggestions to give assistance to the stranded 179 FWs and many other similar situations that may be or are already unfolding before us.

    Singapore may be a young nation but I believe there are no shortages of similar experiences to share in any issues raised here albeit it takes some courage for people to share their aspiring hardship stories simply because a majority of our fore fathers are peasant class immigrants not excluding encounters and experiences that we witnessed while traveling, living or working abroad. However, when the sharing becomes irrelevant and may resulting into personal cyber brawl exchanges or even an implication that I have been there, seen it, live through it and if I can survive through, they (the people who are victims of unscrupulous businesses or manipulators or whatever) should not have it easy. I feel sad towards this kind of thinking albeit the stories told were moving but then again, who does not have a story or two to share that is comparable in magnitude if not exceed what have been disclosed in this thread or elsewhere.

    What I would like to say is that, yes, I sincerely believe a majority of us (me included) have witnessed some of the worst things in our living experiences and encounters then ro sometime in life and most of us (present) had through our own doings survived through till today. That is indeed an achievement that we feel proud of. We certainly hope history will not repeat and the only way to try to prevent history from repeating is to do whatever it takes to ensure one will NOT and NEVER thread in those water ever (so we thought and wish but it is not a guaranteed).

    On the other hand, if we happened to come across similar situation (such like the 179 stranded FWs and many others whether in Singapore or elsewhere), I think people who had gone through a lot of hardship in life tend to empathize with the victims mentioned herein. I would certainly ENCOURAGE, fellow citizenry or fellow earthlings should within our ability to give a helping hand, more so for those of us who had experienced similar or worse situation. I am sure people with conscience will have no joy to just stand by and watch without doing anything when you can even if they are total strangers.

    Please remember, HELP is not and may not necessary have to be associated with monetary assistance. We should also respect people who think otherwise for whatever reasons they may have. After all, it is their decision to make. There are no hard and fast rules that whenever we hear, read or see such heart wrenching situation unfolding before us, that it is a mandate to give assistance, let your inner conscience guide you. Why allow distractions to set in?

    Personally I am not even sure how many of us (including myself even though I am not badly affected ~ at moment) can pull through this current recession that no economy experts or leaders worldwide are willing to predict or project or have any plausible clue how long this will continue through. That is how serious the issues facing us all (not just Singaporeans). This might be recorded in the history books that the worse kind of recession ever witnessed in a global scale in the beginning decade of the 21st century. It is better to collaborate, look out for each other around us and be cohesive, try if we must and can to weather through this recession together. WE Human kind are the thinking animal and a man made problem can and will be resolved by none other then WE the Human kind.

    SIncerely,

    Observer (SG-HK)

    59) gemami on December 20th, 2008 10.24 pm

    Hi Observer,

    Thanks very much for your wise words. I am touched and I do understand that sometimes it is best to ignore such confrontations. I tried, I really did. Now, I am doing this for one reason only, that Moshedyan be able to see the coldness in himself, not my own glory. It is very painful for me to write these words and they bring back floods of unpleasant memories. My hope that this will help him find the armth of the human that is in him.

    So here is part 3.

    Let’s up it another notch, Moshedyan. Let me ask you. Have you stared death
    in the face, Moshedyan? I have, not once, not twice, not even three times but
    countless times.

    Have you seen a friend blow his brains out in front of your very own eyes,
    Moshedyan? I have. It was reported in the Chinese papers way back in 1987.

    Have you seen people you know disappearing into the deep blue sea in front of
    your very own eyes, Moshedyan? I have, and I had to pull them out days after
    they submerged and disappeared. What more is that I had to face the families of
    these friends. Do you know how a father, a mother, a brother and a sister look
    like when they see their son and brother in front of them, all bloated up with
    empty sockets in his eyes? I know, I was there, remember?

    Have you seen friends, oh I love the deep blue sea, disappearing into it and never
    to be found? I have, Moshedyan. I saw them disappeared before my very own
    eyes.

    Have you held the hands of a stranger, dying by the roadside, the victim of a
    hit and run, and talking to him to stay in there and that help was on the way?
    I have Moshedyan. He died in my arms, a stranger, a victim of some cold
    blooded coward who left him to die.

    Now Moshedyan, do you think I have good reasons to be angry with the
    world? Do you think I have good reasons to hate the world? Do you think I
    ought to be cold, uncaring, angry, hateful and set myself in to my little own
    corner and wish the world would be engulfed in darkness, for all I care?

    No Moshedyan. Life’s lessons like these are for people who are special.People
    who are strong. People like you and me. We use our life’s lesson not to brag
    and boast that we have suffered while others have not.

    We use these lessons to reach out and make the world a better place where
    others need not have to go through what we have gone through.

    I have said enough, Moshedyan. Please, you have been put through the
    furnace. You ought to come out as gold. Be the gold that you are and know
    that the furnace cannot burn you no more. Let the gold in you shine for others.

    Love them. I join Joshua to give you my hugs.

    Peace to you.

    60) patriot on December 20th, 2008 10.45 pm

    Dear gemami and Observer(SG-HK);

    I am sadden that this thread had developed in the manner it did up to now. I was trying to cool tempers down, but unfortunately I did not succeed.

    Our dear Observer(SG-HK) is now offering us some understandings of worldly matters which I hope we will conscientiously and sincerely take into considerations. We live in a tiny but complex society, much thank to our 43 years of pragmatic leadership that is only interested in economic developments. Most of us are here trying very hard to tell those living in ivory towers that things are not as rosy as they are telling us day in day out.

    Golden Era, every aspect of our country is fundamentally sound, people will not be left out for medical treatment, children wll be given education even if they are too poor and what not assurances were spouted. BUT, WE, THE PEOPLE ARE THE ONES FACING THE HARDSHIPS WHILE THEY TALK BIG.

    Gemami, there are needs for us to leave some problems for the RESPONSIBLE PEOPLE(as their liabilities). SINGAPOREANS SHOULD NOT RUSH TO SOLVE EVERY PROBLEM FOR THOSE RESPONSIBLE AND THE AUTHORITY.

    I not saying that we should not help people, quite the opposite, I will not hesitate to help whenever I can and I will exhort everyone to do so. HOWEVER, I DO HOPE THAT THERE BE MEASURE AND PROPORTION IN DOING SO WHEN DONATING CASH(MONEY) AND DONORS TO KNOW WHERE AND HOW THEIR CASH DONATIONS GO AND THEIR USES. Blind faith, loyalty, trust and belief are not reliable.

    It is my hope that this comment will not cause any discomfort to other fellow netizens. Let us cut as deep as possible into issues and subject matters, delve as much as our knowledges allow us and try our best to set aside personal indignations. Let peace be with us.

    Yourshumbly: patriot

    61) gemami on December 21st, 2008 7.37 am

    Dear Patriot and Observer,

    I offer my most humble apologies for the way things have panned out in this thread. It was never my intention for it to be so and I am sure you know my primary concern was sensitivity.

    I shall not proceed any further with this discussion with Moshedyan after this post in the hope that I can do my part to bring common sense back to this thread.

    I had only one intention when I returned to offer my story, which is for Moshedyan to realise that there are others out here who have faced as much as he did. Like Observer said, every one of us have our stories to tell.

    I know I have deviated far away from the subject but I felt it was necessary because I cared for the writings of Moshedyan.To me, personally, I felt he has a lot to share with the people around him and he can do this by letting go of what he termed, my nature. To me it is not his nature, but the nature he believe that he is. Loose the temper and the beauty of his nature will shine through. I was only looking for this, nothing more, nothing less.

    So you see, Patriot and Observer, I was hoping for beauty and warmth from one who had lived his life so coldly and even as his coldness made him write the hurtful words he had written in reply to me, even as I asked that he show respect to my wish to keep my privacy to myself, his barrage of personal attacks did not end.

    It was this that made me open up and share my stories in the hope that he sees me qualified to comment the way I did and to call for him to be warm and loving. It will not matter to me after this if he choose to take my advise or not. I have done what I needed to do. i was hoping for him to see the real person that he is, not the cold, hard and heartless person that he believe he should be.

    Once again, Patriot, Observer and all my dearest friends in TOC, I offer my most humble apologies and I regret having to drag all of you into this.

    62) moshedyan on December 21st, 2008 1.51 pm

    [i]only, that Moshedyan be able to see the coldness in himself, not my own glory. It is very painful for me to write these words and they bring back floods of unpleasant memories. My hope that this will help him find the armth of the human that is in him.

    So here is part 3.

    Let’s up it another notch, Moshedyan. Let me ask you. Have you stared death
    in the face, Moshedyan? I have, not once, not twice, not even three times but
    countless times.[/i]
    off all the person in this world
    you asked me this question?
    i danced with lucifer everyday
    which part of my postings didnt say i was supposed to be DEAD
    even the changi south kindhearted doctor according to his diagnose on me
    i am dead defitenitely dropped dead 20 years ago
    yet he got no bloomin idea or science that i am still surviving
    when i was in not 1
    but 3 great hospitals of ours
    i am the best guinea pig for the housemen on practical trainning on hands
    mind you
    the good houseman that dot on me happenned to drop dead
    yes really really dropped dead in his living quarter by the hospital
    why?
    he die for on my behalf instead?
    all he did was just to thrown his laundy down from the 4th floor to the ground so that his parent can bring home to wash
    it gok stucked on the 1st floor balcony(you know those old hdb designed
    he climbed over
    he slipped he fall breaking his skull
    yuou want more?
    in london when the ira bomb that goes off accidntally in baywater cheap hotel W2(favourite haunt site for the ira activists)
    it was next to my hostel
    lucky for me
    or it is God that says
    it not my time yet
    that stupid bomber stayed in the open view
    not the hidden windowless one
    which is adjacent to my hotel room
    it went off
    killing him and some other poor hotel guest
    i was unharmed
    even slept through…
    still not enough?
    hungry for more
    how many of you ever ride a bike
    for example using the CTE as an example during daytime
    on a weekday
    have you ever seen an open gap or traffic free for 5 mins @ all?
    in london the infamous notorius M1 is a roadkiller
    on 1 winter late noon
    black iced
    i skidd my 500cc bike
    i fall off right in the middle of M1
    @ that moment
    i said to myself
    where is the tunnel of light
    what a surprised
    no vehicle behind
    no giant lorries as well
    best of all
    there was some workers( whom you will never ever see on an M1 repairing some bend or whatever) just 5 meters away
    immediately they run over
    moved my bike dragged me to safety
    so please don’t come challenging me
    the death wish
    it NOT my time
    for i have said before
    i am gifted with a 3rd EYE vision
    no not for me to play 4Ds or ToTo
    for me
    to see the world as real
    and passed it throughout the world
    called me joanofarc if you want to
    but i prefer
    noelofarc
    (try do with a search engine on noelofarc..you would be surprised again
    beside moshedyan or matagandhi)
    now you still want to share with me
    YOUR experiences
    or is it a private matter?
    have you ever tried ridng SOLO
    on a motorcyle from singapore to bangkok?
    if not
    why not?
    i have

    63) Observer(SG-HK) on December 21st, 2008 4.16 pm

    Dear 62) moshedyan on December 21st, 2008 1.51 pm

    Thank you for your closed death encounters sharing. It takes a lot of courage to be able to do just that. Appreciate your candidness and kudos to your live fighting tenacity. However I think you are smart enough to know too that the world are filled with people of different characteristics and some may not be as strong a life fighter as you are and these are the people when in dire situation will appear to be hopeless, weary and needed outside help to weather through it.

    From your sharing (I believe you have more installed), well, by at least one count, some good fellow earthling who are strangers to you then did pull you to safety when you were down with the motor bike accident. The world is not that cold after all right? I think you have a gift in you and wouldn’t it be nice to put it in good use?

    You appeared to be (based on your writings) a religious person and that god had given you a rare gift. Wonder whether you could be kind enough to shed a light or two with your futuristic vision when would this recession come to an end? While you are contemplating, I am sure your foresight vision will see many sufferings encounter by less-fortunate fellow Singaporeans and other earthlings worldwide in the months or years to come passes you by. It will be indeed very kind of you if you might think of publishing your prophecy of the coming events, the world will be spared of this unwanted sufferings. I am sure at least TOC can accommodate it. Of course, the choice is yours to make.

    I like to end my comment with this note. Being a staunched believer and advocate of Freedom of Speech, Expression and Choice (with social responsibility strings attached ~ simply put exercising self censorship when expressing controversial sensitive issues); I like to think that we all are matured thinking adults and do understand that we are just readers and posters hosted by TOC and certainly, respect should be accorded to TOC and the author or authors of the subject matter published for opinion and feedback. Like my cyber good friend Patriot and others had correctly noted that TOC has been doing a wonderful job so far as an alternative source of the daily happenings that affects Singaporean and for being accommodating even when views expressed had digressed slightly from the original intent of the article where our MSM fall short of advocating. I believe Andrew and TOC will welcome you to publish an article (or even become a regular guest writer) of my aforesaid request if you will be kind to accept this invitation.

    Once again, moshedyan, my fellow Singaporean, thank you very much for sharing your personal encounters and life experiences, you have inadvertently provided insights that you need courage to fight on and to live out your dreams. I believe amongst the 179 FWs mentioned in this article, there will be some who possess the same kind of Fighting spirits like you do and someday will be able to share their stories with their siblings, friends, fellow men or us (TOC readers and posters) like you have done. They may be down but they are certainly not out. With a little help from caring people who had donated their valuable time and food aide, and now that MOM had step in to intervene, I think at least some perhaps will return to normal living soon (hope).

    To Andrew, TOC and readers, please accept my sincerest apologies for digressing. If you feel that this comment is inappropriate, please remove it from posting as you deemed fit. Thank you.

    Sincerely,

    Observer (SG-HK)

    64) Zeitgeist on December 21st, 2008 4.52 pm

    Somebody must have the last word………………………..word.

    65) moshedyan on December 21st, 2008 8.08 pm

    [i] It will be indeed very kind of you if you might think of publishing your prophecy of the coming events, the world will be spared of this unwanted sufferings. I am sure at least TOC can accommodate it. Of course, the choice is yours to make.[/i]
    in my other forums as contibutor
    i have always shared my prophecy and my prophecy is quite accurate
    as mentioned i will alway coontribute
    if the moderator don’t start deleting/banning me
    now you know why youngpap keep banning me
    its not that i want to use multinicks
    as someone here says
    why must i alway want to write the last words?
    why should i shut the fu>k up
    so that the other party emerged as victor?
    in my 1 decade of debating/rebutting
    many ^losers^
    resorts to use moderators’ skirts
    to chase me away
    even ntuc who invited me to participate
    also guranteed it would not dictate me the way i write or whatever
    in the end what happenned small men appear edit/delete
    even resort to ban me
    please remember
    i am here to contribute
    by MY style
    my owned creativity
    read if you want to
    if not
    just ignored/do not clicked
    i am not here
    for mr popular contest
    i am not bothered
    nor would i bowed to other people demands
    and last but not least
    if you or anyone here
    want to know more
    just seek the toc managment here
    if i am permitted to contribute
    my versions of whatever is happenning around us
    local and foreign
    the last forum i participate
    was in a village in lancashire britain
    with my owned topics
    with photos and pictures

    unfortunately
    the site was shut down by the lancashire local paper big boys bullies
    they don’t want to know the hidden truth
    too many skeletons
    this they must have learnt from pap grc tatics

    another famous sport forum too was shut down in
    INDIA
    espn india
    where i was a moderator
    on a special sections
    this sections i moderate come under
    no bars rules
    you can swore
    you can curse
    1 hell of a hotforum
    simply because
    the paskistani/indians sportreaders
    simply hates each other
    i am there to keep the peace between them
    with my humours
    that sites was closed
    dued to economic depression
    which happenned 2 years ago…
    ole yes
    by the way
    my real real original nick is
    still
    moi
    banned in too many sites
    run a checkthrough
    on sgforum/hardwarezone/vrforum/youngpap as well
    guranteed moi is the number 1 BANNED list
    other than that
    have a nice day
    opps
    you were asking me
    what do i see from now…
    i see only 1 thinggie
    if you want to survive
    make it big
    go CHINA…
    yes china
    for there is no signs of economic depression
    work there if you have an opportunity
    don’t demand too high
    guranteed
    you have no regrets

    66) Zeitgeist on December 21st, 2008 8.38 pm

    How we react to the horrors of life
    that through our misfortune we encounter
    varies
    How we deal with the trauma experienced
    from the harshness of reality
    differs

    67) pugdragon on December 21st, 2008 10.19 pm

    Wow, moshedyan. I just finished watching The Dark Knight, & you seem as wise & experienced in tough & bad things in life as The Joker.

    It’s always good to have people with strong philosophical views about life & aren’t afraid to have their opinions heard. Somehow, people with such strong views aren’t well-received in this country. I don’t know why, but it seems like people around you are always ready to put you down. People who don’t believe in free speech & is intolerant of differences. Ironically, that’s what the majority of Singaporeans are, from my observation of my surroundings & immediate friends.

    People here leaving comments aren’t afraid to voice their opinions, & we definitely need more people like these in the country.

    Do not hate differences. However, everyone has their rights to. In the end, it boils down to what every single individual wants to believe in, & whether to agree with or disagree with the rest of the world.

    Personally, on the subject of the topic, I’d prefer them to get their owed salaries paid & go back to their country. I stay in an area with very high foreign worker density, it’s not exactly the most beautiful & comfortable neighborhood to live in, & it’d definitely benefit from lower population density.

    In the 1st place, companies should not even hire people “just in case” they’re needed urgently. A soccer manager doesn’t hire 8 super mega star strikers & have the majority of ‘em waiting for field time. If companies & gov are responsible bodies, they consider the plight of these workers should they not have enough work, & the comfort level of citizens in regards to country crowdedness.

    PAP, nice try, but not quite there yet. I hope the country’s leader would do much better & free us all.

    68) moshedyan on December 21st, 2008 11.06 pm

    [i]pugdragon on December 21st, 2008 10.19 pm Wow, moshedyan. I just finished watching The Dark Knight, & you seem as wise & experienced in tough & bad things in life as The Joker.

    It’s always good to have people with strong philosophical views about life & aren’t afraid to have their opinions heard. Somehow, people with such strong views aren’t well-received in this country. I don’t know why, but it seems like people around you are always ready to put you down. People who don’t believe in free speech & is intolerant of differences. Ironically, that’s what the majority of Singaporeans are, from my observation of my surroundings & immediate friends.
    [/i]

    indeed life is tough
    life is hard
    for the weaker beings
    we tried to assit
    by voicing out
    as loud as i CAN
    by the end of the day
    those i tried to help out by voicing
    when called upon
    would even denied they know me @ all
    which is why
    in jalan besar area
    i will never stand for any solo elections
    even if i had millionaire$ (which i do know a few)
    because i know
    you know when the isa agent knocked on my kopitiam table
    all suddenly illang faster than a soccer 3 min toilet breaks…
    even my owned siblings was SHOCKED
    when i comfronted the real ex-lta minister
    when he do his walkabouts in jurong west
    if any of you ever see him
    asked him did he recalled
    1 fine sunday morning in jurong west shopping centre
    did somebody challenged you
    UNPREPARED?

    69) Observer(SG-HK) on December 21st, 2008 11.31 pm

    Dear 65) moshedyan on December 21st, 2008 8.08 pm

    Thank you for your advice. Very insightful and kind of you indeed. There might be a problem though, for someone who can’t speak a word of Mandarin or ‘Putonghua’, how to survive there though? China is so big, which province or which industry or work should one chooses if they decided to pack their bags and take up your advice?

    What about America, Japan or EU states? They are after all the current three largest economies in the world. You do not see a future for these countries? Those emerging economies like (in no particular order) India, Australia, Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, Vietnam, Dubai, South Africa, and so many more. What about them? Surely your worldly futuristic vision does see something in them albeit it may not appear to be rosy. I kind of think that they needed your help as well. Don’t forget our very own home, Singapore. Surely, you do not like to see us all poor souls crumble like match sticks right?

    Anyway, I think this is off topics and it will be good if you can write an article of what you see. I am sure TOC will welcome your submission but of course, every site does have their house rules. I have always believed that Respect is earned not a given. I am sure as insightful and a gifted person as you are would not disagree with this point of view. Would you?

    By the way, I do not think people who contributed their previous comments are looking for fame and I believe many will agree, it just mean that we are concerned citizenry and are interested to share our point of views in a civic manner.

    Sincerely,

    Observer (SG-HK)

    70) Observer(SG-HK) on December 21st, 2008 11.35 pm

    Oops..typo error..should be “precious comments” instead of “previous comments”. My sincere apology.

    71) moshedyan on December 22nd, 2008 5.25 am

    [i]Anyway, I think this is off topics and it will be good if you can write an article of what you see[/i]

    please clicked here
    http://theonlinecitizen.com/2008/12/re-thinking-our-economic-expectations/#comments

    72) gemami on December 22nd, 2008 7.58 am

    Hi Observer,

    Many thanks for your wonderful advise and I regret that I did not heed it when I knew it was the right thing to do. Well, I am at peace with myself because I did what I did when I followed my heart, like I always do in my life.

    There was a period time though when I would vent my frustrations on almost anything. But I have since changed because I realised , through some good advice given by a total stranger, that life is more beautiful than we think it is.

    I was reluctant and had refrained from sharing my own personal experiences because deep down I knew there will be no end to it in such kind of arguments. I would tell a story, another one will come in as a rebuttal with more intensity than my own. Then I would offer another one and another rebuttal. For example, if I were to counter his IRA story by saying I have seen a friend’s face blown up into pieces before my very eyes, what good would it do? He will come back with something else like he is doing with practically every comment posted here. I know this type of people. I have dealth with many of them, am still. If only teach of them would see the problem that is himself.

    I know stroking the ego of such people might solve half the problem but I believe that doing do will do such people more harm than good because they will die without knowing how beautiful, warm and loving this world is or can be.

    Yes we can go on and on about our life stories but in the exchanges above, I will be the first to run and hide my face should someone enters the fray and asked if we have really faced life in its extremities? Do we know what it is like to have all that you have yesterday but to find out today that you have lost a leg, a hand or an eye? How can we then compare to such harsh realities? Where will I hide?

    Just like we the manner in which we are looking at these 179 Blangadashies, it is not the ‘ME’ factor that is important but the THEM factor. If we cannot be sensitive to this, then we have lost the flame in our hearts. Any arguments thereafter will be under these two beliefs.

    There is no gift of prophecy here, let’s not try to be too nice. One who believes he can prophesy has a big ego. One who believes he can prophesy with accuracy, has an even bigger ego. I now understand why I was up against it from the beginning.

    We have wasted enough TOC space stroking his ego and I offer again my apologies to TOC, friends and readers.

    I concede that I have been foolish to think the impossible. I admit that I have turned away the better advise of wise and true friends. I have learned a wonderful lesson in this exchange and I am looking forward to Christmas for this wonderful gift of understanding.

    From the bottom of my heart, I thank you both Observer and Patriot. I deserve all the scolding I get but I am happy because my dance with Lucifer ended the day I decided it to be so, and to embrace LOVE.

    73) Observer (SG-HK) on December 22nd, 2008 10.36 am

    Dear gemami,

    Thanks for your kind words. I am glad to hear that you see the point me and patriot is trying to make. It is always hard to fathom what a person thinks. It is also difficult to instigate people to try to read between lines. The world is round and regardless of how we view things, at the end of the day; the end result may turn out to be the same. The difference is some see it earlier and the others may still be wondering why it had happened. Some may even resulted into allowing hallucination to set in and living in virtual reality. But you have got to admire people who do that, as they really do believe in their perspective of life. Life can be stressful if you allowed it to take hold and not deal with it.

    We are only HUMAN and we are prone to make mistakes. The importance is to live with our mistakes and be at peace with it. I have a fair shares of ups and downs in life (still on roller coaster ride as of today), but heck, that’s life. Some wise people I have met in life repeated this call to me: “Young man, to be successful in life, the importance is to be courageous to pick yourself up where you fall, it is no big deal should you fall, for you owe yourself a good living and the world is big enough to accommodate one more dream”.

    Here’s wishing you and all in TOC a Merry and Happy Christmas season.

    74) patriot on December 22nd, 2008 10.50 am

    Dear all;
    Observer(SG-HK), gemami, Gilbert Goh;

    let us all be courageous, fair and kind.

    A Merry Christmas and Many Peaceful Years Ahead to All !!

    patriot

    75) moshedyan on December 22nd, 2008 11.56 am

    [i]For example, if I were to counter his IRA story by saying I have seen a friend’s face blown up into pieces before my very eyes, what good would it do? [/i]
    have you or even dared to challenge the former lta min ister in his face
    when he was doing his walkabout galant flowered tour in jurong west?
    have you ever talk to the dbs ex minister chairman in his face and TELL him
    i am still fu>king unemployed and what can you help me in my dire straits?
    last but not least
    have you even been told in YOUR face
    when wongcansing comes
    you are to avoid or be invisible if you want something to be done?
    ira makeup story?
    ~zhee~
    as i have said
    get out of your blooming aircon office
    take a walk……..

    ps if your friend face got blown up
    you would not be here
    and yes i do have platoon mate ass being blown when his 60mm mortar misfired
    i too was the same mortar man
    how come his as s got blown
    my wasn’t?
    simply because he were posted to another unit
    now you see
    it not my time to die yet?
    share with us a little of your gift
    if you have any
    come on
    be a sport

    76) gemami on December 22nd, 2008 12.09 pm

    Dear Observer, Patriot and friends,

    It is I who should thank you all instead. Like I said, it’s going to be a very Merry Christmas for me. I hope and wish all of you have a wonderful one too.

    Peace to all.

    77) Zefly (aka Joshua Chiang) on December 22nd, 2008 12.18 pm

    moshedyan,

    Shalom. Peace be with you.

    78) Kenpachi on December 22nd, 2008 11.42 pm

    F workers should be helped caused they were tricked into coming here. If you were tricked into entering a foreign country on the pretence of work and left stranded with no money, you will definitely wish the local government can help solve your plight. Or at least give you a free air ticket to your home country.

    However, we should only help those who deserve it and i feel that these foreign workers are deserving of it. We should be kind and generous, but only to the right people. Remember Huang Na case? Singaporeans donated generously and that b***h mother rewarded herself with a bigger house in China. She is still laughing at our stupidity now. And the NKF case? I don’t have to say more.

    Furthermore, most of the times as read in the papers, bangladeshi and indian workers seldom abuse the donations given to them. Sorry to sound prejudice, most of the time is the China ppl who misuse the donations and use it to help themselves, not for a good cause.

    Seriously, wth is our Members of Parliament doing, always say the govt will help ppl but the MOM has only done is to collect money and then say cannot return..bla bla blah. It’s a disgrace that MPs don’t even care about this foreign workers plight and when the ppl get involved and donate, the MPs come out last minute and then say” See we organised this thing.”. C**p.

    The government then always supports those ang moh expats on the basis of “foreign talent”. Yet when AIG collapses during the financial meltdown, the “foreign talent” ang moh boss is the first to quit and run off to another country, where they can get fatter paychecks. Whereas, these banglas helped us build our houses and toil hard under the sun.

    I think it’s time for the “Malaysia March08″ assault, next election we must vote in 50% PAP and 50% opposition, see whether PAP MPs still talk cock. The Malaysians done it and we can do it.

    79) moshedyan on December 23rd, 2008 9.59 pm

    [i]Kenpachi on December 22nd, 2008 11.42 pm F workers should be helped caused they were tricked into coming here. If you were tricked into entering a foreign country on the pretence of work and left stranded with no money, you will definitely wish the local government can help solve your plight. Or at least give you a free air ticket to your home country[/i]

    i am going to tell you a real real story here
    happenned in singapore 5 or 6 years back
    fellow foreign indians
    cheat fellow foreign indians
    ok here goes
    3 little indian men were chanting
    hay hu ra thumb tump
    hay hu ra thumb tump
    opps that was the red indian raindance story
    wrong book
    (chuck one cornor)
    arh here is it
    hay hu ra thump tump
    ok ok
    you all gotta the drum beat
    ok to add spice
    3 little indian men were thumpin and dancin around the coconut tree
    happy now
    till 1 other indian joined them
    this starnge indian is no ordinary indian
    he one mudder fricker farkin slavemaster
    he tell these 3 innocent injun
    do you know in singapore
    little india is paved with gold gemstones from king solomon minds
    just bent over
    picked any stones that glitter
    guranteed you make a fortune
    some other injun came
    they digged out our lta cateyes in our highways
    now you know why lta new roads are all red l.e.d.s lioa right?
    so this 3 injun chaps
    sold/mortgaged whatever they have
    make 3 nice madeinindia passports
    came to singapore
    wearing smart new long sleeve shirts
    yes brand new
    i even saw the folding crease lining on it
    when i said i saw
    i meant with my eyes
    not some straits times press medias….
    they arrived
    in changi airport
    they were met by a foreign injun just liked their fellow countrymen
    don’t asked me what caste this airport injun is
    its wasn’t include in this story
    this ^local^ foreign talent injun says
    you 3
    abunehneh
    handover your document/passports
    i am going to bring you
    to your new employer for paperworks
    he drove the 3 little injun men on his opened lorry pickups
    from changi airport
    he drove them to chuachukang cemetry
    really chuachukang cemetry
    don’t believed asked phuachukang
    his mother was selling chendol @ the cemetry on a hot afternoon
    so this 3 little injun
    stand
    (chuachukang cemetry have no aircon visitin room to rest your tired feets hor
    not even a cup of drinkin water hor)
    they wait
    and wait
    till somebody called in the mata
    you know those blokes who wore long pants
    not the kakied short pants version
    the policemen knew what already happened
    no needs interpreter from the indian high commision
    the police aircon patrol car give them one cool of a ride
    straight to immigration detention cell in joochiat
    that where yours truly come into the picture
    what yours truly does or do that
    is for a 4 eyed vision only
    no needs to go into details
    i listened and asked not them
    but the immigration personnels
    who told me
    such incidents happenned again and again
    so i asked
    what would happenned to this 3 little poor injuns?
    immigration says
    they will have to inform their family in india
    to make alternative repratration airticket back home
    the indian high commission
    will only provide a piece of paper to allow them to come home
    but i says
    eer
    ugm
    they already mortgaged/sold whatever belongins they had
    before comin over
    the immigration personnel
    asked me
    is that our problem?
    now you see
    why am i ^cold^
    what could i do?
    when the indian high commision did nothin
    beside typin a letter
    i asked one last question
    if the family in india have no funds to send over
    so how?
    immigration says
    they would be holidaying in kaki bukit till this matter is resolved
    i further asked
    why don’t OUR govenment grant them temporary employment liked cleanin hawkers centre tables
    so that they can earned their journey fare home
    the immigration personnel mubbled
    so who is goin to give the green/humane right?
    ministry of manpower?
    the endings
    you all figured it out…

    80) first-timer on December 25th, 2008 11.42 pm

    HI everyone, it’s my first time visiting this site. There’re a lot of (emotional) sharing and finger pointing which government agency / who is to blame etc etc. Thought we should do a better job at addressing their pressing needs at the moment, at least. Just wanna do what I can within my means, am not smart enough to prophesize or embarrass any public servant on the streets, but I believe in karma and God.

    Going back to the issue — OK, the workers need detergent, soap, toothpaste and toilet papers? Sure. Where to send them to? The workers were moved to Yishun already? Don’t feel comfortable giving cash although that is the most convenient… I’ll faint if anyone buys cigerettes and beer after getting money…. am I normal to feel this way?

    Appreciate any advice.

    81) The Migrant Workers’ Fuse is Lit « Chemical Generation Singapore on February 27th, 2009 6.12 pm

    [...] are protesting peacefully outside MOM recently. But as their frustration grows, would they become more desperate in their protests? The authorities would seize the chance [...]

Leave a comment





Bottom