By: Atticus
The Attorney-General’s Chambers (AGC) has denied any link between the politically charged academic publications of NUS Law Faculty’s Associate Professor Tey Tsun Hang and the prosecution against him for corruption for allegedly sleeping with law student Darinne Ko in return for improving her grades.
In response to media queries, the AGC said in an emailed statement:
“There is no link between these charges and Mr. Tey’s academic publications and writing,”.
Speculation started after Prof Tey said in a statement to the press:
“I am known to speak up, amongst other things on the Singapore legal system”. He further went on to state that his writings are in good faith with no ill intent and his defense will be in a similar vein.
Despite being mainly an academic specializing in equity and trusts, Prof Tey has also been known to publish articles containing critiques of the Singapore political system.
Recently, a blog has been started that has republished some of Professor Tey’s more politically charged articles.
Prof Tey obtained first class honours from Oxford University and practised law in Malaysia before being hired by then Dean of the Faculty of Law Professor Chin Tet Yung to teach at NUS Law faculty.
Subsequently, Prof Tey left academia to enter the legal service in the Supreme Court as a Justice Law Clerk during the tenure of the then Chief Justice Yong Pung How.
Prof Tey subsequently left to practice in the top litigation firm in Singapore, attaining the rank of Associate Director.
Prof Tey then went on to become a District Judge, after which he returned to academia at NUS Law Faculty.
The recently started blog, entitled “Singapore Consensus”, collates the writings of Prof Tey, a Malaysian citizen, that are directly critical of the Singaporean legal system.
In a 2010 article entitled “Judicial Internalising of Singapore’s Supreme Political Ideology” published in the Hong Kong Law Journal, Tey argued that “Right from the beginning of Singapore’s nationhood, an obvious and unbridgeable disconnect appeared – between its leadership’s political ideology and the aspirations on human rights and constitutionalism of its legal community.
In another article published in 2010 in the Hong Kong Law Journal entitled “Criminalising Critique of the Singapore Judiciary”, Tey argued:
“The ruling People’s Action Party (PAP) of Singapore legitimises its authoritarian political regime – and insulates it from substantive scrutiny – via a three-pronged strategy: first, through its tightly controlled media and communications channels; secondly, by delivering an admirable economic performance and, creating and maintaining an awe-inspiring standard of living; and thirdly – and most importantly – through its legal institutions. However, there are profound logical flaws and stark absences of consistency in the judgments that help secure this legal state of affairs”.
The other articles Professor Tey has written in a similar vein are likewise equally critical of the Singaporean political and judicial system.
One of his articles is titled “Death Penalty Singapore-Style: Clinical and Carefree”.
In this article, Prof Tey argues that “Singapore has developed a jurisprudence that death penalty and capital proceedings are no different from other minor criminal proceedings. Instead of scrutinising criminal legislation on their substantive fairness, the courts have instead consistently restricted their adjudicative function to one of procedural assessment. In so doing, formalistic and textualist techniques are employed to achieve crime control ends at considerable expense of due process”.
In another article dealing more directly with the political system in Singapore titled “Singapore’s electoral system: government by the people?”, Prof Tey critiques the Singapore deviation from the Westminster political model as follows:
“In its post-independence constitutional development, the dominant People’s Action Party political leadership had made a series of constitutional amendments to its original electoral system, introducing innovative schemes such as Group Representation Constituencies, Non-Constituency Members of Parliament, Nominated Members of Parliament and the Elected Presidency. These changes have resulted in an electoral system that is so different and divergent from the Westminster model that it should be regarded a unique regime of its own. This paper advances the view that the constitutional evolution of its electoral system is reflective of a political vision structured along elitist lines – underscored by a desire to restructure the voting behaviour of its citizens, and ensure predictability and the preservation of the status quo. It has been driven by paternalistic assumptions about what is beneficial for its citizens.”
In light of questions Yale University faculty have raised about academic freedom in Singapore, the AGC’s next steps to ensure that the case of PP v Tey Tsun Hang is not perceived as political persecution will probably be almost as important as securing a conviction against Prof Tey.

You May Also Like

Nestlé adopts Workplace by Facebook as its global internal communication tool

Nestlé has adopted Workplace by Facebook as its global internal communication tool,…

另一“女佣洗冤录”? 被指盗雇主存款菲佣成功脱罪

高庭对前女佣巴蒂案在今年9月的判决,无疑在本埠抛下震撼弹,巴蒂原本被判监禁26个月,但高庭推翻国家法院判决,法官陈成安也形容樟宜机场集团前主席廖文良一家可能存在“不当意图”,女佣巴蒂有充分理由投诉人力部,而廖家“先下手为强”将他开除。 不过,10月30日,高庭亦推翻另一和女佣有关的判决。一名菲律宾籍女佣,原本被指控盗取老顾祝银行存款8千元,被判坐牢一年。不过经上诉得直无罪释放。 名为波蒂拉(Portela Vilma Jimenez)的50岁菲佣,原本负责照顾89岁的老雇主夫妇,雇主妻子不良于行。 但是,老雇主指控波蒂拉在2017年1月和2月期间,八次盗提老雇主银行存款,面对多达10项偷窃控状。波蒂拉不认罪,也指责老雇主四度非礼她,还要和她发生性关系。 波蒂拉也指老雇主趁老妇熟睡时闯入她房间,老雇主提议500元任摸,前者为了钱而答应。国家法院法官早前下判时,认为老雇主非礼波蒂拉一两次,但没必要一再不偿,并指责女佣口供前后不一,判她坐牢一年。 不满刑罚的女佣则透过来自尤金(Eugene Thuraisingam)律师楼的两名大状黄舒旺和夏珊娜,再次上诉,并提出如下疑点: 老雇主声称2017年2月初发现有未经授权提款,但审讯时却揭露当时根本没人从他户口提款 老雇主发现后,却拖了三个星期才报案 老雇主声称钱包一直在身上,那么波蒂拉如何拿到提款卡?…

日语回答日媒询问 前进党梁文辉:外籍PMET可减10巴仙

新加坡前进党助理秘书长梁文辉昨日(14日)在记者招待会上以日语回答日本媒体的提问,表示新加坡的PMET外国人才中,可以削减其中的10巴仙。 梁文辉昨日在出席记者会上,有日本媒体询问有关专业人士、经理、执行员和技师(PMET)的问题时,梁文辉则以日语表示,新加坡目前约有40万外国人才从事PMET的工作,因此可以削减其中的10巴仙。 他补充,“基本上,新加坡政府说,没有就业准证(Employment Pass),整体的竞争力就会受到影响,但我们并不同意。我们认为就业准证和S Pass是可以减少一部分,如10巴仙左右,这样就有数以万计的就业机会给国人。” 梁文辉也承诺,若进入国会,也会主动将提呈给政府。 梁文辉于1979 年获政府颁发海外优异奖学金(Overseas Merit Scholarship),并前往日本一桥大学(Hitotsubashi University)就读经济学。 尽管前进党在大选中并未获得任何席位,但前进党的成绩不俗,获得两个非选区议员的席位。…

New contractor employed by Foodfare at Whampoa was charged in court this year

It was earlier reported that after NTUC Foodfare took over the iconic…