Deborah Choo/

A typical day started at 5am. Hannah (not her real name) would do some household chores and feed the family’s many pets. Mid-mornings saw her shuttling between her employer’s fruit stall and his daughter-in-law’s photo shop in Clementi. In the afternoon, there would be more chores at the daughter-in-law’s house. In the evening, she had to clean and close up the fruit stall and photo shop before heading home to scrub the toilet and iron clothes.  The two families’ four cars required washing once a week. A normal day ended at 2am. Hannah stuck it out for 11 months. And then she ran away.

It was a decision borne out of desperation.  Hannah had previously written letters and made phone calls to the Ministry of Manpower but all they did was tell her her case was under review. On October 7, 2010, she had called the police.  But after paying her a visit and speaking to her employer, they informed her that the matter was out of their jurisdiction.

“They told me that they could not help me because it wasn’t an abuse case. The police also told me that my employer had the right to send me back to my country,” said Hannah.

She packed her bags that night. The next morning, enroute to the fruit stall with her employer, Hannah dashed out of a train at Cityhall and made her way to a shelter run by the Humanitarian Organisation for Migrant Economics (HOME).  She’s been living there since.

Hannah is a victim of what HOME”s President Bridget Tan describes as “psychological abuse”. There are no physical scars, yet the impact can be devastating.  Victims complain of a host of problems including sleep deprivation, stress, self-esteem issues and physical and mental exhaustion. Hannah is also illegally deployed. Cases like Hannah’s have prompted migrant rights groups and the Human Rights Watch to call for foreign domestic workers to be covered under Singapore’s Employment Act. Doing so would help ensure that they are not overworked and compel employers to give them weekly rest days, maternity benefits and other labour protections. But it’s a plea authorities here seem unwilling to heed.

When TOC approached the Ministry of Manpower for comment, we were told to refer to a letter published on the Straits Times on September 21, 2010. The letter, written in response to feedback from Vincent Wijeysingha, Executive Director at NGO Transient Workers Count Too (TWC2), explained that foreign domestic workers are not included in the Employment Act “due to the nature of their job”. It also said, “Protection for FDWs has gone beyond legislative measures. For instance, MOM maintains a dedicated helpline for distressed FDWs and actively educates employers on good FDW employment practices.”

MOM did not answer TOC’s request for statistics on the exact number of complaints it receives each year in relation to psychological abuse. The exact number of victims is hard to quantify. Unlike Hannah, many choose to suffer in silence. Quite apart from the relative lack of official interest in such cases, the women are also constrained by economic considerations. Most have paid hefty recruitment fees in order to secure work in Singapore. They live in fear of being sent home should they incur the displeasure of their employers.

For Hannah, these are uncertain times. It’s been six months since her escape and she is still waiting for MOM to complete its investigations into her case. She remains in Singapore on an Special Pass, which has to be renewed monthly. HOME is currently helping her to find a new job. Hannah hopes to stay on once the investigation ends. Despite her ordeal, she’s trying to be optimistic – hoping her next employer won’t be like her first.

 


HELP keep the voice of TOC alive!

If you like this article, please consider a small donation to help theonlinecitizen.com stay alive. Please note that we can only accept donations from Singaporeans. Thank you for your assistance.

Do you have a flair for writing? Volunteer with us. Email us your full name and contact details to theonlinecitizen@gmail.com

59 Responses to “Hannah’s Ordeal”

  1. DON'T talk big 1 June 2011

    talk big 31 May 2011
    many of us talk big here, sg allow to have maid, not in many western country, and many of us here also have maid and also abuse them, for sure u can see for yourself every morning the miad washing car everywhere!!!!
    {if u don’t have one u are nuts! coz life here is like heaven, a luxury, no need for toilet washing?}

    > talk big

    so you also have a maid?

    do you wash your own toilets or …?

    please,talk big,you r nuts!

    pls don’t TALK COCK,talk big.

    Reply
  2. Bad Singaporean

    You miss my point,nevertheless its better to sound silly than to be an ignoramus.

    Reply
  3. iFUCKpissoff4aliving 1 June 2011

    Pisstoff 1 June 2011
    @ go nuts

    YOU IDIOTIC STUPID IDIOT … Did you lost the ground or has you been sleeping all this while ???

    My advised … GO NUTS AND DROP DEAD … IDIOTIC ASS***HOLE.

    …………..
    no wonder you are a frickin F UC K I N pissoff…
    you don’t hav the ability to be YOUR own boss…
    yet i do..maybe a poor rooftless boss
    butt never the less… i am still a BOSS in rank way way on top of you
    told you already…
    i FUCK the loudest..the most lethal as well and i can used another handle to FUCK you direct..
    without
    under MODERATION directives

    Reply
  4. Anthony 1 June 2011

    This is the kind of education Singaporean gets… See the comments given above by those two?

    This is the reason we must first change our education system and our leaders. Because ppl look up to their leaders for example. And a REAL education base on good moral values will create a better Future for all Singaporean.

    Reply
  5. free and rich 1 June 2011

    my no virgin filipino msid slept with my hubby. i set it. he is ugly fat man and longing to be rich $ free. my maid can take care of him now.
    maid good, my hubby good, me good…all good..no loser :>

    Reply
  6. free and rich 1 June 2011

    tips; maid come in handy when u wanna to get rid of ur hubby, and proceed with a divorce.
    - let ur hubby choose the maid
    - unreasonable scold the maid (no beating)
    - no phone call, no social, no letter
    - allow ur hubby to protect/hunt her
    - leave sometimes for them to ‘develop’
    - install a hidden camera
    - finally, last burst at her and get out of the hse. leaving ur hubby and maid alone
    - that’s it. kanna trapped… proceed with divorcee and get $$$ agreements.

    Reply
  7. iFUCKu4aliving 1 June 2011

    @iFUCKu4aliving

    Read my nick … wahaha … lolz

    Reply
  8. Pisstoff 2 June 2011

    @iFUCKpissoff4aliving

    Quoted by iFUCKpissoff4aliving :

    no wonder you are a frickin F UC K I N pissoff…
    you don’t hav the ability to be YOUR own boss…
    yet i do..maybe a poor rooftless boss
    butt never the less… i am still a BOSS in rank way way on top of you
    told you already…
    i FUCK the loudest..the most lethal as well and i can used another handle to FUCK you direct..
    without
    under MODERATION directives

    ======================================

    Somebody really so Pisstoff @ Pisstoff … HAHA .. LOL :)

    OIC .. Bragging about being a boss .. huh ?? So are u happy now being a boss with shallow brains :) BTW .. what’s your company name ??? Do u mind sharing ??

    Didn’t u realize u are making a mockery of yourself ??

    Why should I waste my time on a complete idiotic bloke like you … *sigh* :(

    P.S. I dedicated the above poster nick specially for you bloke : iFUCKu4aliving
    … Yup read his nick alright :)

    Reply