~By: Leong Sze Hian~

The Government Whip Gan Kim Yong in response to a query from Today, said that the whip will be in place when Parliament debates a new formula for ministerial salaries – ““There is no intention to lift the whip. We would only do so if the subject is a matter of conscience," he wrote in an emailed reply” (Channel NewsAsia, Jan 12).

If a debate to decide how much the people in Government should pay themselves, is not considered “a matter of conscience“, then what is?

According to the dictionary, “conscience” is “the sense or consciousness of the moral goodness or blameworthiness of one's own conduct, intentions, or character together with a feeling of obligation to do right or be good”. 

If high pay has really enabled Singapore to recruit the best talent into Government, then why do the PAP not even have the confidence and openess to allow MPs to vote on this issue, without being forced to vote according to the party line?

On the issue of lifting the whip, a Mr De Costa alerted me to some interesting things which the Emeritus Senior Minister said in the 2006 general elections.

“Mr Goh also elaborated on what he means by raising the whip in Parliament so that Mr Sitoh and Mr Eric Low can raise opposing views.

Mr Goh says: "Actually I was trying to find a way out to a question where somebody said that there are people who wanted an opposition. They also want upgrading, so in my mind I thought well we can have the best of both worlds – we can have upgrading and if they elect Sitoh Yih Pin and Eric Low, we can lift the whip for them. That means we can also have an opposition voice in Parliament.

Let's make it clear, I mean they are PAP MPs so it is not quite the same as an opposition MP. But what I hope Eric Low and Sitoh Yih Pin would do regardless of whether the whip is lifted or not is to speak their minds frankly. Whatever views they have, even though they disagree with the government or with the party, they must voice them in Parliament – that's important. So it's my advice to Sitoh Yih Pin just now.

I say, 'Look, in order to establish yourself later on as an MP, you must not come across as a 'yes' man. Come across as Sitoh Yih Pin, who has got a view, who has got a voice; be prepared to raise difficult issues to the government so the whip is actually immaterial.' It's whether he is prepared to speak on policies when he has a different view and whether the government 
will support it." – CNA/de” http://newsgroups.derkeiler.com/Archive/Soc/soc.culture.singapore/2006-03/msg04957.html

So, was the whip lifted for the new PAP MP for Potong Pasir,Sitoh Yih Pin, in the recent Parliamentary debate on Ministerial Pay? If it wasn't, why not? The then Senior Minister promised it in 2006. Doesn't it show that senior PAP ministers are just like the ordinary politicanns they decry: promise inconvenient things that they later conveniently forget?

Finally, on Potong Pasir constituency, Mr De Costa showed me a letter which a government agency had written to him responding to a letter which the MP for Potong Pasir had written on his behalf. It reads, in part, “I refer to your representation through the honourable MP for Potong Pasir GRC”, which was copied to the MP for Potong Pasir GRC.

And I thought (and so did Mr De Costa) Potong Pasir is a SMC.Does it mean that Potong Pasir may become a GRC? Or is it “an honest mistake”? Remember Tin Pei Ling redesignated her ward as a SMC


Support TOC! Buy Uncle Leong’s book here!

 

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

Temasek's investee company Bayer now being sued in Australia

Last month, Australian news media reported that a Melbourne gardener has become…

冒牌专才费雷拉 疑涉泄露1.4万艾滋病患个资

昨日,卫生部宣布国内医疗体系再度爆出严重病患个资外泄资料,这次是1万4200名艾滋病患个资被人公开上网,卫生部长颜金勇为此道歉。 根据卫生部文告,警方是在22日通知卫生部,而相信涉及泄露艾滋病患个资的,正是曾在2017年被控诈欺、欺骗公务员、拥毒和造假文凭的“冒牌专才”费雷拉(Mikhy Farrera-Brochez )。 费雷拉是在2007年和我国医生吕德祥(译音)相识,在2008年1月至2016年6月,持工作准证,到我国和吕德祥同居。 他的37岁医生男友吕德祥,为包庇有身为艾滋病带原者的费雷拉,被指在2008年3月20日和2013年11月29日,以自己的血液样本偷龙转凤瞒过人力部,让后者得以通过就业准证申请。 为了获得就业准证,费雷拉需通过医疗检查。于是在2008年三月,费雷拉假装到吕德祥诊所抽血,吕德祥则把自己的血液试管贴上费雷拉的名字,让费雷拉医检过关。 至于费雷拉,凭借着造假文凭,成功瞒过人力资源部和淡马锡理工学院长达八年,他甚至获得淡马锡理工学院“赏识”,获准在院内开设儿童心理诊所提供咨询服务。 自诩“天才神童” ”假专才“费雷拉在2010年接受媒体访问时,自诩”天才神童“,声称自己在三岁时就能通晓希伯来、西班牙和英语。 他告诉记者其母亲特蕾莎金,是英国有名的儿童青少心理学、儿童神经学和天才科学和数学教育学者。但是随着他在2016年因拥毒被捕,英国媒体《独立报》决定调查费雷拉身世背景,结果踢爆费雷拉的母亲纯属虚构。 2013年,人力部接到举报指费雷拉是艾滋病带原者,要取消他的准证。费雷拉辩称是被诬告的,于是在同年11月22日,和吕德祥故技重施,再度用吕德祥的血液瞒天过海,避过检验。结果,人力部接到检验报告后,继续让费雷拉保留准证。 二人同居住所搜出吸毒器具…

Activists charged for protest

A group of acitivists who took part in a protest outside Parliament House earlier this year has been charged for illegal assembly. Another group of activists holds a protest against the ERP hike.

Khaw Boon Wan announces that mask-wearing will be made compulsory for public transport

Minister of Transport, Khaw Boon Wan has just announced on his Facebook…