~By: Jen~

I am very disturbed by the new Edusave Character Award scheme by the Ministry of Education to reward good character in students with hard cold cash. This award according to MOE’s Minister Heng Swee Keat, is to recognise students who exhibit values such as respect and who demonstrate exemplary civic responsibility through their behaviour and actions.

I am all for cultivating good values, but to actually have a scheme to give money to students for doing and being good just goes against the grain of what it means to be a good person. I believe most of us were taught by our parents to be good and to do good not for reward, but because, it is good for us and society in general. Isn’t this a universal principle?

Yet, now we have this pay-money-for-good-behaviour scheme. What exactly were our education minister and the ministry thinking? What values are they trying to inculcate in our impressionable young? That it literally has to ‘pay’ to do ‘good?’

As it is there are already so many award schemes at schools that pay cash to reward students. The Edusave Awards for Achievement, Good Leadership and Service (Eagles) and bursaries for most improved in school grades (which some kids have learnt to game the system to make money by deliberately doing badly in first half of the year).

I believe using reward as a motivator can be useful and good, but it cannot be the easy way out and cash should not be used in certain situations. Whatever happened to the good old days when reward meant getting a good book? Okay, maybe not a book in today’s internet age, but surely MOE can come out with more creative ways of motivation than just cash.

One cannot help, but wonder, if there is a political agenda behind the Edusave Character Award scheme that comes post-haste after GE2011. Based on Mr Heng’s comments in Parliament, he said such a scheme is not just to drive home the importance of character building among the young but it is to “ultimately, prepare them for a world of unknowns… It is more about how to process information, discern truths from untruths, connect seemingly disparate dots and create knowledge even as the context changes…”

Read Mr Heng’s quote again and one wonders how to connect the disparate dots between what he said with the new character building award. If one were to read between the lines or dots, it sounds like it may be part of a plan to mold young minds in a certain way so that it is aligned with the thinking of the PAP’s values. Shape the young so they can be “reasonable” and “speak with reason” in line with their definition of reasoning and make sure the kids here do not grow up to be the vocal “lunatic fringe”?

It will be interesting to know what criterion is used by MOE to judge if a student has good character and values. Will it be considered good character if a student is an activist who criticises a government policy because he or she views it as questionable and detrimental to the people? One wonders.

Despite all the initial signs shown by the PAP during GE2011 that they will try to be more understanding and open-minded, some of their actions post GE like introducing this Edusave Character Scheme leaves a bad taste in the mouth. This scheme is regressive as it smacks of political manipulation to shape young minds and teaches the wrong values of paying cash to reward good behaviour. As it is, Singaporeans are already being accused of being too money minded and here they go teaching our young the wrong values. Seriously, what is our government thinking?

 


This article first appeared on Jentrified Citizen. We thank Jen for allowing us to reproduce it here.

 

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
You May Also Like

民主党邀民出席 3月16日“减轻生活费用”政策发布会

新加坡民主党将在本月16日(周六),下午2时正,于新加坡民主党总部(宏茂桥3道,第62街,#02-30, Link@AMK工业大厦),举办“减轻生活费用”政策发布会,诚邀民众和支持者出席。 民主党文告表示,为了打造一个具同情心、包容心和持续发展的家园,为了让国人有充足的理由投出神圣的一票,民主党将拟定首个减轻生活费用替代方案,于本周六公布。 民主党指出,新加坡被列为世界上生活费最为昂贵的国家之一,而日益高涨的生活费是所有人民共同关注的课题,但是执政党人民行动党却未能改善,反而视情况加剧。 民主党怒斥在2015年大选期间,行动党总理李显龙,曾向人民承诺会努力解决生活费问题,改善人民生活和负担。“可是行动党却通过提高各种行政收费,增加了民众的痛苦。自上届大选以后,短短三年内他们提高、或者拟议提高了14项行政收费。” 该党也列举诸多已经被调涨,或将可能被提高的各种收费的开销,包括:水费、停车费、车辆进入市区费、市政理事会杂费、电费、煤气费、巴士费、幼儿班学费、大学学费、工艺学院学费、消费税、二氧化碳排放费、数码数字服务费和柴油税。 推出系列方案大选宣言 民主党表示,该党将提出,如何降低人们生活费用的建议,以便减缓新加坡各阶层人民,包括青年、家庭主妇、年老父母、退休人士以及商家在经济上的负担。 除了生活费的替代方案,该党也将陆续推出一系列、针对各课题的替代方案,包括教育、房屋、人口、医疗保健、经济、马来族群和部长薪金等,然后将把各种方案集成一本书,在大选前把详细方案发布给国人审查。 吁民投出有价值的一票 该党相信,此史无前例的举动,能向新加坡国人证明了他们的决心。有关的替代方案也将成为该党的里程碑,更是该党在来解答选的宣言。 民主党希望人民在来届大选中落实选民责任时,不仅仅是抱着反对的心态,而是真正感到手中投出值得的一票。  

Pest control specialists to tackle rat infestation at Bukit Batok

[youtube id=”4QtJMDPGWkA” align=”center” mode=”normal”] Pest control specialists turned up at the hill…

大巴窑中民众俱乐部外举笑脸卡片 警要求范国瀚协助调查

两个月前,社运份子范国瀚在大巴窑中民众俱乐部(Toa Payoh Central CC)前,展示一张画着笑脸的卡片。 昨日(20日),范国瀚在脸书分享,接到警方来函,要求他在周日下午2时,到东陵警署协助调查。 警方也告知他,上述举动涉嫌违反公共秩序法令。不过范国瀚表示,当时只是在现场举卡片拍照后就马上离开。 当时范国瀚是为了声援两名年轻人,他们倡议环保议题,其中一名青年同样在大巴窑中民众俱乐部和邻里警局前,举起写着“新加坡值得比原油更好的”(SG IS BETTER THAN OIL)的卡片,并把照片上载到社交媒体。 不过警方较后表示,青年在进行上述活动时,未申请准证。…

Progress Singapore Party elects new CEC, former Secretary-General Francis Yuen steps down

Progress Singapore Party (PSP) has announced its Central Executive Committee (CEC) after holding its election on Sunday (26 Mar), which will serve for two years until March 2025.