By Leong Sze Hian

I refer to the Ministry of Manpower's (MOM)  Report on Wages in Singapore, 2011, released on 29 June.

Basic Wage vs Total Wage

In 2011, the real total wages rose by a mere 0.1%, while real basic wages declined by 0.8%. However, the MOM report, which uses a different method of calculation, tells a different story. They claim that real total wages have grown by 0.9%. They have, however, taken the employer CPF contributions as part of their computations.

In the past, median wage was computed without taking into account of employer CPF contributions. The measure of “real total wages” appears to be a fairly new development amidst a rising political dissent in Singapore.

In any case, a historical comparison using past benchmarks still means that median wages fell by 0.8% last year. Why then, is the ministry claiming otherwise?

The new methods are also applied to the computation of CPI (“Consumer Price Index”), where rentals on owner-occupied accommodation are removed. Hence, with their new reporting style, Real Total Wage, after adjusting for CPI gave an increase in real wage of 1.9% in 2011. This, however, was not the practice in the past.

I find it rather strange that we apply this new formula as most Singaporeans already have a house but do not own a car (thus no COE, inflation). Using the new CPI makes the report inaccurate and extremely misleading.

Growth in real wages in line with productivity: Really?

Labour productivity rose by 1.0% in 2011. Over the period of 2000 to 2011, labour productivity grew by 1.7% per annum while real total wages (including employer CPF contributions) increased by 1.6% per annum.

So what was the increase in real basic wage excluding employer CPF contributions from 2000 to 2011? Without access to the full data, one can only guess. And my guess is that, real wage increase between the period of 2000 and 2011 was even lower than the 1.6% per annum.

Majority did not give one-off special payment to RAF

As of December 2011, only a minority (4.1%) of private establishments with RAF (Rank-And-File) employees had given or intended to give a one-off special payment (recommended by the National Wages Council (NWC)) to their RAF employees while 5.1% are still considering whether to give.

The above shows that most employers (95.9%) did not follow the NWC's recommendations. Shouldn't our unions do something about this? Otherwise, workers' real wage increase may continue to languish in the doldrums, with decreases in 2008 and 2009, and a meagre rise of 0.5% in 2010, and 0.8% last year. With inflation hovering at 5%, how are people going to cope? Putting out numbers that are misleading will not solve the problem.

There is even more disheartening news below.

32% of establishments did not raise wages in 2011

The proportion of private establishments that raised total wages of their workers in 2011 was 68%. The average quantum of wage increase of these firms was 6.6% which was lower than 7.6% in 2010. The proportion that cut wages in 2011 (8.5%) was higher than 2010 (8.2%), with quantum of wage cut the same at 4.3%. The remaining 23% kept their wages unchanged in 2011.

If we adjusted for inflation, how many workers received a real wage increase? The numbers will be even more dismal.

Some profitable establishments did not raise wages

The majority of profitable Category A (84%), Category B (76%) and Category C (63%) establishments raised wages, only slightly by 53%. Loss-making Category D establishments either froze or cut wages.

So, if we follow Lim Swee Say’s logic that productivity increase leads to firms' profitability and hence an increase in real wages, then the pertinent question of why these profitable firms did not raise wages looms large.

Overall unit labour cost rose

The overall unit labour cost (ULC) rose by 3.4% in 2011.

Some get paid less as they grow older?

In most countries wages tend to rise with age as workers gain experience. It is a different story here however. The wages of plant/machine operators, cleaners, labourers and other related workers were largely flat for younger workers before declining for those in their mid-forties onwards. Age typically works against workers in physically demanding manual occupations. 

Service and sales workers also generally received declining wages as they grew older. For example, the Ratio of Median Monthly Gross Wages for those age 60 to 64 relative to Age Group 25 to 29, was 0.65.  This means that by the time you are age 60 to 64, you may be getting about 35% less pay than when you were age 25 to 29. If you adjust for inflation, your real pay may have literally been cut to the bone!

Other low-wage workers include food/drink stall assistants ($900), the lower-paid hawker/stall holders (prepared food or drinks) ($1,200), waiters ($1,300) and cleaners in offices and other establishments ($815).

The numbers and statistics presented by Ministry Of Manpower are thus inaccurate and does not give the real picture. Then also, why is this protrayal presented to the public? I leave you discerning readers to formulate your own thoughts.

Edited by TOC Kumaran Pillai and Leonard Khaw

You May Also Like

Polling agents behaviour reinforce stereotype of PAP being “arrogant and not playing fair”, says WP polling agent

A polling agent for the Worker’s Party in Marine Parade GRC said…

【选举】欣赏俄作曲家用音乐传达民意 方月光冀望把群众心声带入国会

民主党在此次选举,派出林文兴、达曼胡理、江伟贤和方月光团队攻打马西岭-油池集选区,硬撼由原国家发展部长黄循财领军的人民行动党团队。 尽管仅派出11名候选人,不过民主党在此次选举也算“下足重本”,竞选团队不乏拥有博士、医学教授等资历的人才。至于该党秘书长徐顺全在武吉巴督不屈不挠的精神,选民看好后者有望此次选举突围而出。 除了早前本社介绍过的林文兴、达曼胡理和江伟贤,马西岭-油池集选区团队中的方月光背景亦不可小觑,据民主党竞选官网介绍,他曾在外交部、内政部和国防部等机构担任要职,也曾担任新加坡驻北京大使馆首席秘书(政治与经济)。 事实上方月光还是奖学金得主,以及英国剑桥大学音乐系毕业生。《联合早报》稍早前专访方月光,从轻松角度谈他过去曾作曲追太太的经历,以及家人如何看待他从政等。 询及他将用什么古典乐来形同现在的新加坡?方月光表示自己最喜欢的音乐家是俄国作曲家肖斯塔科维奇(Dmitri Shostakovich),因为他的音乐非常有深度,也有很多政治内容,每个作曲都是对整个国家政治文化的表态。 “他有他的想法、理念,但也尽量把民生透过音乐带出来,让领导阶层者也能听到民声”。 他也表示这也是自己的理想,期望若有机会入国会,能把群众的心声带到国会。  

Transport Minister issues targeted correction direction to Facebook over posts about alleged Woodlands MRT closure

Another correction order has been issued under the Protection from Online Falsehoods…

ICA have begun trials on new iris and facial scan system for immigration clearance at Tuas Checkpoint

A new trial for contactless immigration clearance has begun at the Tuas…