Connect with us

Health

Malaysia: Why are police still probing contract doctors over strike despite Health Minister’s assurance, Lembah Pantai MP asks

Published

on

KUALA LUMPUR, MALAYSIA — Lembah Pantai Member of Parliament (MP) Fahmi Fadzil today questioned why police investigations are still being carried out against contract doctors who participated in a strike on Monday despite Health Minister Adham Baba’s assurance that the medical officers will not be penalised for doing so.

Speaking in Parliament on Wednesday (28 July), Fahmi referenced a report by local news portal Malaysiakini stating that police took the statements of medical personnel at the COVID-19 quarantine centre in MAEPS Serdang at 3am today.

“I am seeking for an explanation on whether the minister’s statement is for the whole government, or just the Ministry of Health, or on behalf of certain parts of the government, or even from himself,” he said.

Dr Adham told Parliament that contract doctors who participated in the walkout will not be subjected to any disciplinary actions or punishment, as it is their right to go on such a strike.

A day prior, Astro Awani reported Dang Wangi district police chief Assistant Commissioner Mohamad Zainal Abdullah as saying that investigation papers related to the Hartal Doktor Kontrak movement will be opened.

This is despite Inspector-General of Police Acryl Sani Abdullah Sani’s earlier statement that police have received no indication that the strike will threaten public order.

Asheeq Ali, a lawyer representing the frontliners at the centre, tweeted on Wednesday that the questioning began as early as 11.45pm on Tuesday.

“12 doctors who had participated in #HartalDoktorKontrak had their statement taken. Police will continue their probe tomorrow for doctors not on duty tonight,” he said.

Asheeq noted that the investigations were reportedly carried out over the alleged unauthorised presence of media at the treatment centre. An officer from the Health Ministry had reportedly made a police report regarding the incident.

Calling the probe “uncalled for”, Asheeq said that the police’s move to take the medical frontliners’ statement in the wee hours of the morning “in a time where they are on duty saving the nation” is “a form of intimidation that cannot be compromised with”.

“They are already overworked and exhausted, and you can still allow this? Shame!” he said, addressing the Health Ministry.

Speaking to reporters on the sidelines of the Parliament sitting on Wednesday, Dr Adham said that his ministry is not involved with the ongoing police investigation.

Reiterating his earlier stance in Parliament, he said that the Health Ministry has issued instructions to have disciplinary action taken against the doctors who had participated in the strike.

Dr Adham also told reporters that MAEPS is not under the purview of the Health Ministry, but is under the National Disaster Management Agency, a body under the authority of the Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department.

When asked why the doctors were questioned by police for up to four hours, the Health Minister said that the question should be directed to police.

The massive walkout on Monday took place after Prime Minister Muhyiddin Yassin’s “half-baked” proposal to lengthen their contracts has failed to placate their demands regarding their security of tenure.

Former health minister Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad on Tuesday sought clarification from Dr Adham on whether the government will consider pushing for an extension of eight to 10 years instead of the two years proposed by the government.

“You cannot do postgraduate studies in that (short amount of) time,” the Kuala Selangor MP told Parliament.

Finance Minister Tengku Zafrul Tengku Abdul Aziz earlier told Parliament that affected contract doctors will have two years added to their contracts.

The extension will cost the government approximately RM1.2 billion.

Contract extensions merely “a sugarcoating statement to shut us up”: Contract doctors reject short-term proposals mooted by PM, Cabinet

Among the key suggestions earlier put forth by Muhyiddin and the Cabinet regarding the security of tenure of contract doctors include offering a two-year contract extension for medical officers, pharmacists, and dental officers who have completed their compulsory service.

For medical officers and dental officers who have been selected to do the relevant Masters’ programme, the government may grant a four-year contract extension, according to the government’s plans.

In a statement on 24 July, the Hartal Doktor Kontrak movement said that simply adding more years to such contracts is not a means of solving the problem but merely “a sugarcoating statement to shut us up”.

“We know well how the system works, we are not buying it. Nobody wise enough will accept it. Stop giving us a half-baked solution given by people who are not even in this field, or don’t even know how the system works, or maybe don’t even bother to think thoroughly about it because the problem is not theirs,” they added.

Stressing the importance of offering permanent posts to all contract medical and other healthcare officers, Hartal Doktor Kontrak said that the lack of job security for contract doctors will not be remedied through such proposed extensions.

“A contract medical doctor is forever seen as a second-class doctor compared to their permanent counterparts,” they said.

The movement added that the short duration of extensions is absurd, given that it usually takes “many years” before medical officers are accepted into the Master’s programme.

“An extension of contract for a maximum of 4 years for those accepted into the Master’s programme also seems bizarre, as the duration of the programme itself is a minimum of 4 years,” Hartal Doktor Kontrak noted.

“This shows the (ministers’) lack of understanding in our local specialist training,” they added.

Continue Reading
2 Comments
Subscribe
Notify of
2 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Health

Survey reveals one-third of Singaporean youth struggle with severe mental health issues

A national study by the Institute of Mental Health reveals that 30.6% of Singaporean youth suffer from severe symptoms of depression, anxiety, or stress, driven by factors like excessive social media use, body image concerns, and cyberbullying. The findings emphasize the need for early intervention and targeted mental health strategies.

Published

on

A significant portion of Singapore’s youth are experiencing severe mental health challenges, according to a comprehensive national survey conducted by the Institute of Mental Health (IMH).

The National Youth Mental Health Study (NYMHS), released on 19 September 2023, found that 30.6% of individuals aged 15 to 35 reported severe or extremely severe symptoms of depression, anxiety, or stress, with key risk factors including excessive social media use, body shape concerns, and experiences of cyberbullying.

The study, which surveyed 2,600 Singaporean citizens and permanent residents, highlights the growing mental health concerns among Singaporean youth and suggests the need for more targeted interventions and support systems.

Mental Health Issues Prevalent Among Youth

Anxiety was the most common mental health issue, with 27% of respondents reporting severe or extremely severe symptoms, followed by depression (14.9%) and stress (12.9%).

These findings underscore the high prevalence of mental health issues among young people, particularly in those aged 15 to 24, who were more likely to report severe symptoms compared to older participants.

According to the IMH, young people who were female, single, unemployed, or had lower levels of education or household income were more prone to severe mental health symptoms.

For example, youth with monthly household incomes below S$5,000 were more likely to experience severe anxiety​.

Key Risk Factors: Social Media, Body Image, and Cyberbullying

The study identified three major factors linked to severe mental health symptoms:

  1. Excessive Social Media Use: Around 27% of respondents reported using social media for more than three hours daily, which was associated with a significantly higher likelihood of severe mental health issues. Youth with excessive social media use were 1.5 to 1.6 times more likely to experience severe symptoms of depression, anxiety, or stress​.
  2. Body Shape Concerns: About 20.2% of youth had moderate to severe concerns about their body image. These individuals were 4.9 times more likely to experience severe depression, 4.3 times more likely to experience severe anxiety, and 4.5 times more likely to suffer from severe stress​. Such concerns were often linked to social media exposure, which can perpetuate unrealistic beauty standards and increase dissatisfaction with one’s body.
  3. Cyberbullying: One in five youth (21%) reported being victims of cyberbullying. These individuals were approximately twice as likely to report severe mental health symptoms compared to those who had not experienced such harassment​. The anonymity and pervasive nature of online bullying exacerbates the mental health toll on young people, according to the study.

Demographics at Higher Risk

The study found that specific demographics were more vulnerable to mental health issues. Young people aged 15 to 24 were more likely to experience anxiety, depression, and stress, particularly females, those who were single, and those with lower levels of education, such as junior college or vocational qualifications​.

The Malay ethnic group was also found to have a higher prevalence of severe mental health symptoms compared to other ethnic groups​.

Barriers to Seeking Help and Sources of Support

Although about 69.1% of those with severe mental health symptoms sought help—primarily from family and friends—a significant portion of young people hesitated to seek professional support.

The top reasons included concerns about privacy, fear of judgment, and doubts about the effectiveness of professional services​.

Among those who sought help, family and friends were the most common sources of support (57.9%), followed by self-help measures (31.1%) and medical services (20.1%)​.

However, the reluctance to seek professional help highlights the need for continued efforts to destigmatize mental health treatment and increase awareness of available services.

Protective Factors: Resilience, Social Support, and Self-Esteem

The study also identified factors that helped mitigate mental health challenges. Youth who reported higher levels of resilience, perceived social support, and self-esteem were significantly less likely to experience severe symptoms of depression, anxiety, or stress.

This suggests that fostering strong support networks and building resilience in youth could play a critical role in improving their mental well-being​.

Government Response and Preventive Measures

The findings of the NYMHS support Singapore’s broader National Mental Health and Well-Being Strategy, launched in October 2023, which adopts a whole-of-government and whole-of-society approach to addressing mental health concerns. Schools have already begun integrating mental health education into their curricula, equipping students with the knowledge and skills to manage their well-being.

Additionally, the government introduced the Parenting for Wellness toolbox in September 2023 to help parents manage their children’s screen time and promote healthy social media usage.

A guide on responsible social media use, expected to be released by mid-2025, will offer further strategies to mitigate the negative impacts of excessive screen time and online harassment​.

Future Implications and Policy Development

Associate Professor Swapna Verma, chairman of IMH’s medical board and co-principal investigator of the study, emphasized the importance of early intervention.

“Not all individuals with severe or extremely severe symptoms of depression or anxiety have a clinical condition, but being in such states for a prolonged period of time can be detrimental to their well-being,” she said​.

The study’s data will help policymakers and healthcare providers develop more targeted approaches to address the mental health needs of Singapore’s youth, especially those most at risk.

Associate Professor Mythily Subramaniam, IMH’s assistant chairman of medical board (research), stressed the need to pay attention to issues like excessive social media use and cyberbullying, noting their “tremendous impact on youth mental health” and the importance of preventive measures​.

Support for Youth Facing Mental Health Challenges

Young people dealing with mental health challenges in Singapore have access to various resources:

  • CHAT (Centre of Excellence for Youth Mental Health): CHAT offers a safe and confidential space for youth to seek help through online and face-to-face mental health assessments and support.
  • Institute of Mental Health (IMH): IMH provides a comprehensive range of mental health services, including outpatient consultations and inpatient care. Youth in crisis can also seek immediate assistance from the 24-hour Mental Health Helpline at 6389 2222.
  • Samaritans of Singapore (SOS): SOS offers emotional support for those feeling distressed or experiencing suicidal thoughts. Their 24-hour hotline is 1767.
  • Health Promotion Board’s National Care Hotline: This hotline provides immediate emotional support for those in need and can be reached at 1800-202-6868.
  • Counselling Services: School-based counsellors, as well as community-based services such as TOUCH Youth, provide further avenues of support for young people grappling with mental health issues.
Continue Reading

Health

Malaysia reports new mpox case in man without recent international travel

Malaysia has confirmed its first mpox case of 2024 in a male patient, the Health Ministry reported. The patient is in isolation and stable, with authorities monitoring his contacts. This brings the total confirmed cases since July 2023 to ten, all from clade II.

Published

on

MALAYSIA: The Malaysian Health Ministry confirmed a new case of monkeypox (mpox) in a male citizen, marking the country’s first confirmed case of 2024.

The patient, who began showing symptoms on 11 September, is currently in isolation and in stable condition.

The ministry, in a statement issued Tuesday (17 September), revealed that the patient first experienced fever, sore throat, and cough, followed by the appearance of rashes on 12 September.

He has no recent history of international travel within the past 21 days, and authorities are in the process of identifying and monitoring his close contacts, following strict standard operating procedures (SOPs).

“Out of the 58 suspected mpox cases referred to the ministry this year, one case has been confirmed positive for mpox clade II as of 16 September,” the ministry stated.

“All 10 cases reported in Malaysia since July 2023 have been from clade II.”

The Health Ministry had earlier reported that Malaysia recorded a total of nine mpox cases since the first detection on 26 July 2023, with the most recent case reported in November 2023.

All previous cases had links to high-risk activities, but no deaths were reported.

Global Context and National Preparedness

Mpox was declared a Public Health Emergency of International Concern (PHEIC) for the second time on 14 August this year, due to the rapid spread of the clade Ib variant, particularly from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) and neighboring African nations.

In response, Malaysia’s Health Ministry activated its national crisis response centre on 16 August to enhance readiness and coordinate preventive measures.

The ministry advised the public to take precautions, including maintaining personal hygiene and avoiding direct contact with individuals suspected or confirmed to be infected with mpox.

High-risk individuals experiencing symptoms such as fever, swollen lymph nodes, and rashes are urged to seek immediate medical attention.

Mpox is caused by the monkeypox virus (MPVX) and spreads through close contact with symptomatic individuals.

The incubation period is typically between 5 and 21 days, and patients remain contagious until all lesions have dried up and fallen off.

Continue Reading

Trending