Connect with us

Transport

Unexplained train breakdown along the EWL on Wednesday morning

Published

on

Commuters along the East West Line experienced a train breakdown on Wednesday (21 Nov) morning; While tweets from passengers informed about the delay, there were no specific fault explained. SMRT did not make any official announcement and it seemed there were no station nor train announcement either.

TL posted a tweet at 8:49am that he was stuck at Bukit Batok and asked why there was no update:

And he shared a photo showing the crowds at the station, mentioning a 20 minutes delay:

Other commuters also posted their tweets about the train delay on the Twitter platform:

https://twitter.com/hobimeetsuga/status/1065049153091198977

Kyros Koh shared several photos showing the situation and crowds at the Bukit Gombak Station. He wrote that passengers were forced to alight:

Is Wong was on the train towards Boon Lay and diverted to Bukit Batok without any announcement:

https://twitter.com/lswong12/status/1065050287524667392

Other tweets kept coming from the digruntled passengers:

https://twitter.com/apakaunaksetann/status/1065056164096880640

Gadar Soe witnessed a pile up at the end of escalator and near-miss accident at Bukit Gombak:

https://twitter.com/gadarsoe/status/1065053515804856320

There was no explanation from SMRT and commuters also ceased to post their information and complains about the breakdown after 9:35am.

Continue Reading
Click to comment
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Singapore

SMRT: Train-borne electrical fault behind 10 Oct EWL disruption

In an updated Facebook post on 10 October at 3:56 PM, SMRT confirmed that the train fault on the East-West Line (EWL) at noon was caused by a train-borne electrical fault, distinct from the 25 Sept incident involving an axle box. The faulty train was recovered, and SMRT reassured commuters that the tilt some experienced was normal due to the track slope.

Published

on

SINGAPORE: In an updated Facebook post on 10th October at 3:56 PM, SMRT confirmed that the train fault on the East-West Line (EWL), which occurred at noon on the same day, was caused by a train-borne electrical fault.

SMRT clarified that this fault is distinct from the earlier incident on 25th September, which involved an axle box.

They also reported that the faulty train has since been recovered to the depot.

Acknowledging that some commuters experienced a tilt while aboard the stalled train, SMRT explained that this was due to the slope of the track at the curvature near Tiong Bahru station.

They reassured commuters that the tilt is normal and that the train remained stable.

The disruption occurred around 12.30PM, SMRT a first-generation westbound Kawasaki Heavy Industries (KHI) train stalled near Tiong Bahru station due to the fault.

“All commuters were safely disembarked at Outram Park station,” said SMRT, who also expressed apologies for the inconvenience caused.

During the disruption, SMRT advised commuters to expect an additional 25 minutes of travel time between Outram Park and Queenstown MRT stations towards Joo Koon.

They also announced the availability of free regular bus services and assured passengers that station staff were on hand to assist.

By 1:22 PM, SMRT said train services from Queenstown station to Bugis had resumed.

Earlier, some commuters who were on the train during the disruption observed that it was tilted.

Many took to social media to express their frustration over the EWL latest disruption.

Some reported being stuck on the train between Tiong Bahru and Redhill stations for nearly half an hour, while another claimed to have been trapped for approximately 45 minutes.

This train fault came just 10 days after the resolution of the major six-day EWL disruption on 1st October.

 

Continue Reading

Comments

Commuters report being stuck for nearly half an hour during 10 Oct EWL Disruption

Some commuters took to social media to express their frustration during the East-West Line disruption on 10th October. While some claimed to have been stuck on the train for nearly half an hour, others voiced disappointment over SMRT’s inability to manage repeated breakdowns. Some even sarcastically noted that as public transport fares continue to rise, train faults seem to be increasing as well.

Published

on

SINGAPORE: On 10 October at noon, the East-West Line (EWL) experienced a disruption due to a train fault reported by operator SMRT at 12:31 PM.

Commuters were advised to expect an additional 25 minutes of travel time between Outram Park and Queenstown MRT stations towards Joo Koon.

SMRT also  announced the availability of free regular bus services and assured passengers that station staff would be present to assist those in need.

By 1:22 PM, SMRT said train services from Queenstown station to Bugis had resumed.

SMRT explained that at 12:30 PM, a first-generation westbound Kawasaki Heavy Industries (KHI) train stalled near Tiong Bahru station due to the fault.

“All commuters were safely disembarked at Outram Park station,” said SMRT, who also expressed apologies for the inconvenience caused.

According to comments from commuters on social media platform XiaoHongshu, some reported being stuck on the train which halted between Tiong Bahru station and Redhill for nearly half an hour.

One commuter commented, “I’m really speechless… Just a few days ago, the EWL had a major breakdown and just recovered. I thought things should be safer recently? Yet today I encountered this, the train stopped between Tiong Bahru and Redhill for almost half an hour.”

“SMRT really leaves people speechless. Prices increase every year (they’re set to rise again at the end of the year), yet faults occur one after another.”

“The last incident still hasn’t received a satisfactory response or explanation from the public, and now another one has occurred just a few days later.”

Commuter Expresses Disappointment Over SMRT’s Inability to Manage Repeated Breakdowns

Observing comments on SMRT’s Facebook post, one commuter, who claimed to have been stuck in the faulty train for approximately 45 minutes, expressed disappointment that, despite numerous breakdowns, SMRT still could not manage the situation effectively.

There were also commuters who criticised the communication during the train fault. He pointed out that the announcement made at the station was so muffled that it was unintelligible, rendering it effectively useless.

As a result, He had to look for information on SMRT’s Facebook page to find out about the delay.

Some questioned whether SMRT had conducted proper due diligence checks on all first-generation trains, given that the latest disruption occurred just 10 days after the resolution of a six-day major EWL disruption.

One netizen expressed dissatisfaction with SMRT’s approach to managing first-generation trains.

The comment questioned whether SMRT was waiting for more breakdowns of these trains before deciding to withdraw them from service.

The netizen expressed concern that this delay in action resulted in unnecessary costs for repairs and significant inconvenience for commuters.

A Comment expressed frustration with SMRT’s focus on post-incident announcements, arguing that such actions are too late. He suggested that SMRT should prioritise precautionary measures to enhance the reliability of train services.

Another netizen sarcastically noted that as public transport fares increase, train faults seem to be on the rise as well.

Continue Reading

Trending